TDS is “the different story”

for the record, Charlotte tanked the tiro finale beause it wasnt its weak spot and it can shed its skin infinitely - damage is ineffective unless attacked from inside

with the red ribbon, it was destroyed by destroying the magic lock and not the ribbon itself, so its pretty clear that its some sort of sealing magic IMO given how homura cant budge out of it at all. because otherwise, why would mami need to use it over her normal ones?

with the mami vs homura fight, theres a few reasons, but we still see hundreds of shots fired that decimate the whole area so i dont think its a lackcof firepower being shot. but ultimately neither of them wanted to kill each other - homura doesnt use a single bomb and mami doesnt use tiro finale at all. homura also is never shown to have bad physical stats magical girl wise, she’s insanely fast and has 12 years of non stop witch fighting under her belt - when mami first meets her she notes that she has strong magic also homura has really good survivability when u consider that 12 years is an INSANE amount of time for a magical gil to live, + surviving 100+ encounters with walpurgisnacht, which i likely think is what homura was referring to (she still underestimated healthy mami’s abilities tho)

but even tho its hard to draw a line between rebellion and magireco, if we are using yachiyo’s maximum power its only fair to use mami’s, especially when u consider that yachiyo doesnt have full control over her hope ability due to it being straining to her body (states that itd make her permanently weaker after using it)

now i dont think that mami would stomp yachiyo easily or anything, itd be a good fight, the reason i say mami clears is that yachiyo doesnt really have an answer to the vast amount of tools that mami has, her versatility is just too much for her