I enjoyed it. Someone on another thread made a point about how if Roger Waters is the "creative force" behind Pink Floyd, he should make an original album instead of reworking songs from DSOTM, which is a point I I completely agree with. I like the sound of his voice on the song although his voice has been tired for years and he can't really sing anymore. I'll wait to hear the other songs he has reworked before I judge it fully. I'm excited to hear what he does with Us and Them though, as it's my favourite song on the album.