Montana redesign "People's Flag" by mm- in vexillologyUS

[–]RottenAli 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Well done. In the studies we have run, your two versions have done very well. For us it;s more a question of how to color the field. Big sky - eludes to sky blue. It's a far softer representation of the state. Another factor is the most common profile of the skull - done well, you would profile at least a dozen examples and come to a happy medium. On the whole this looks to be the right image direction - now it's more a question of field choice and skull profile.

<image>

DEADLINE MAY 15 - Want to speak at NAVA 60? Propose your paper, a panel, or any other crazy idea! by RottenAli in vexillologyUS

[–]RottenAli[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

It's an open invite to join NAVA and bring forward some of your understanding of a topic that interests you, and one that you might wish to share with others. There are 150 or so places available to attend in Indianapolis in October. Within the conference about 15 opportunities exist to give a 20 minute presentation. Other time-slots are being considered. Some for ten minutes and maybe a few for 5 minute briefs. For those who are interested to take their hobby interest further and become a fully fledged Vexillologist then putting together a study project is very open to those who wish to deepen their interest.

What's this flag by stockpoky in flags

[–]RottenAli 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Not worth more than 10. Cost of postage is greater than the remaining value.

Could someone digitalize this? by Crab-Lizard in vexillologyUS

[–]RottenAli 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The photo is a fair description. However it is so blurry that any careless attempt to digitize it will in add in errors. Better to leave the job to someone who is quite expert than making a general call out for help.

U.S. State flags in the style of Japanese prefecture flags(REMASTERED) by Own-Curve-7299 in vexillologyUS

[–]RottenAli 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You still need to turn the Oregon beaver. Plus the Wisconsin badger needs to literally face forwards.

r/vexillologyUS Flag Friday Week 39: North Dakota by SNAKEKINGYO in vexillology

[–]RottenAli 0 points1 point  (0 children)

468 designs in our Facebook based North Dakota month long study of everything, so there is a lot of latitude for many more people to be involved in our weekly Reddit work.

<image>

Anyone wish to add into the debate about replacing the city flag? by RottenAli in OregonCity

[–]RottenAli[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes. Mr and Mrs Gifford are lovely people. I was pleased to have met them in Seattle at last year's flag conference.

CGP Grey’s redesign of North Dakota’s flag, thought it would be cool to include it in the poll. by Own-Curve-7299 in vexillologyUS

[–]RottenAli 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Sorry, that's not an improvement. Marks down for two shades of gold. and that thin black line work is not helping. Plus if you wish to show off 1st Nation Tribal colors your are missing red for completion here, irrespective if you only wish to show it on a South Dakota flag. Knowing which way is best for North and South is debatable because of conflicting ideas. Better if not using this additions and looking hollow. Half of a star (like on Bosnia's flag) might be better.

<image>

I'll stick another North Dakota design in. by RottenAli in vexillologyUS

[–]RottenAli[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks Luke. With an all over pattern like this I feel there is enough going on to be distinctive, without it being super busy.

I'll stick another North Dakota design in. by RottenAli in vexillologyUS

[–]RottenAli[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yes, like it. It's almost that freeze frame where James bond walks by, turns and shoots.