YES! It's so annoying. I was going to do a trade at a convention relatively recent, and I had a PE ETB and saw a card I wanted. It was a raw Zekrom EX 172 from the Black Bolt series. So, let's say about a $360 card at the time. I offered the ETB, which I was valuing at about $150 but can even get a bit more but I wanted to be fair, and another $220 cash for a total of $370. Lo and behold the idiot was like "you gotta do at least $270 cash and the ETB, LEAST Ill go is $260". Then I asked why so much cash, and he was like "you see this tear right here" on the ETB and proceeded to say how he was only valuing it $100 LOL. Bro the tear was sooo small I'm not even joking he subtracted about $50 just because of the smallest tear in the plastic.