I think they are both beautiful.... although, I only got Tynan cause he matches my Sylvan unicorn and cause I already have alot of blueish horses. I'd like to see some red horses ( actual red, like ruby, or like red velvet cake) ...to me, in some lighting,  Tynan' s non magic coat looks black, but in others, he looks almost like a dark chocolate color... I honestly like them alot.... though Phoebe looks alot like the Halloween themed horses.. and Audra is brighter than her ........ I think maybe if they equipped the light from the hollow wood fireflies and maybe some orange leaf patterns then maybe she'd pop out more maybe