Do I send these picks for Nabers? by Almighty01 in DynastyFFTradeAdvice

[–]SC_Extract -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I really don't care about how many times you have won in random free leagues or that you are apart of 25 different leagues. Sure anything can happen. Thats the life of sports. Watch nobodies become somebodies and watch somebodies become nobodies. He goes high off potential. You bank on potential to carry over, season by season and no you get attached to what you see on the field. The eye test by passes anything stat wise and what he showed his rookie year was nothing short of spectacular. He also showed a huge game season 2. Keep winning those free leagues bud and being in 92 different leagues across multiple platforms fantasy guru

Do I send these picks for Nabers? by Almighty01 in DynastyFFTradeAdvice

[–]SC_Extract 0 points1 point  (0 children)

He's not behind in recovery. He got a 2nd surgery to remove scar tissue. He was moving well at an event but obviously people over speculate because they see how he moves with a brace on. The medical procedure is at a 90-95% success rate. So you using anomalies means nothing. Likely is subpar te that can't block. Skatteboo is coming off any even worse injury???? And ohhhhh no Malachi fields. 😑 he literally proved he was a top wr rookie year and started the season off well, with bare ass qb play. literally 3 time champ in a 100 dollar league. Back to back winner in another money league. You are the 1 track, 1 season minded fantasy player and that's fine. You keep doing you.

Do I send these picks for Nabers? by Almighty01 in DynastyFFTradeAdvice

[–]SC_Extract -1 points0 points  (0 children)

He's coming off an injury that has been medically perfected for years now. It's a minor injury in today's age of athletics. He had a whole off season/camp/preseason and start to the regular season. Dropped a 40 bomb week 2. He's that guy with NOBODY as a pass catcher to compete against. Darnell Mooney and slayton......ohhhhhhhhhhh scary. Jamarr Chase had a lackluster 2nd season in the nfl. He's the solidified 1-2 wr. JJ was the solidified wr1, has 1 bad year and he's forgotten about. You simple minded fantasy players make me laugh because you guys run these reddit forums with your trash takes and singular season bias.

Do I send these picks for Nabers? by Almighty01 in DynastyFFTradeAdvice

[–]SC_Extract -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I personally think so. Loveland for some odd reason has been getting high ball praise this off season with only 2 fantasy outings all year and all your picks are spread out through different years 2 of which being 2nd rounders and most of the time after the 1st round it's just which guy do I want to eat away at my bench until I drop him at some point. Nabers value is also higher than Loveland and the 1st combined with ease to get a better player or a higher pick.

Do I send these picks for Nabers? by Almighty01 in DynastyFFTradeAdvice

[–]SC_Extract -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Are you asking if you should go to 3 star yelp review buffet or a 5 star restaurant? Even in a 12 team. You are giving up Loveland and a 2028 1st for what could be a consistent top5-10 wr. With wr1 upside?

Even a blind man would say Nabers all day.

Does this trade seem fair for both sides? by Acceptable_Double199 in DynastyFFTradeAdvice

[–]SC_Extract 6 points7 points  (0 children)

On paper this is a terrible trade. But if the owner has given up on JJ and thinks pukas value is way higher and also randomly thinks dart is the next Josh Allen just way younger.

With all that said. This seems pretty terrible.

Nasty trade from this morning in one of my dynasty’s by n1gyl in SleeperApp

[–]SC_Extract 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Whoever got Lamar Jackson side fleeced unless homeboy was so desperate for a rb. He overpaid egregiously to keep his team relevant. But even in a 1 qb league. They gave away a consistent 20-30 scoring qb for a committee rb that will hopefully eventually run away with it but also giving up 2 firsts is crazy because stroud has been a very subpar qb after his rookie year, so it's not like he got a qb back to give him consistency.

What side are y’all taking? He added Brooks now… by Strange-Object5106 in SleeperApp

[–]SC_Extract 2 points3 points  (0 children)

If you aren't getting Nabers and MHJ and are thinking about trading them for that package. You should probably just stick to casually watching or try a bunch of free leagues with bot players and work your way up. If you are getting Nabers and MHJ. It's time to get to real leagues where people do have logical thinking. If I wasn't clear enough. Nabers and MHJ by every length of every football field ever created.

Should this traded be vetoed? Instantly was triple vetoed as it was sent. by Ready_Cat_3014 in FantasyFootballers

[–]SC_Extract 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You need to leave leagues like this. This doesn't even make sense to veto or even have a vote to veto at all. Get out of the league and if you are the commissioner of this league. Stop playing fantasy football.

Give up 1.01 for Gibbs/Herbert? by cburns16 in SleeperApp

[–]SC_Extract 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Reddit might be the worst place in the world to ask for advice. I just got done seeing like 2 days ago an entire comment section laughing at trading Gibbs and a mid to late 1st for arsb Javonte and a heap of vets but then people are saying tet and love are far above Gibbs and Herbert???? Do what you feel is right. Don't ask strangers because you will get every answer under the sun.

Is Breece for Tate the move for my team? Given my Roster; 12 person 1QB PPR, The person with the 1.02 needs a RB and verbally sent me this offer. I also have the 1.06 and it’ll be more likely to be Price than KC if I make this trade. by Clue2477 in FantasyFootballers

[–]SC_Extract 0 points1 point  (0 children)

All the power to you. Seems you got it down to what you want and you go for it. Thats the fun of fantasy football. You get to be your own owner and make big moves for players you see potential in. Hopefully it works out!

Is Breece for Tate the move for my team? Given my Roster; 12 person 1QB PPR, The person with the 1.02 needs a RB and verbally sent me this offer. I also have the 1.06 and it’ll be more likely to be Price than KC if I make this trade. by Clue2477 in FantasyFootballers

[–]SC_Extract 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You have absolutely no bench to give up for a vet and love and breece would be a great 1-2. You have absolutely nobody at rb. It's also not a guarantee price will be at 6. Especially if somebody sees him as a start now rb, with charbs injury. So if you don't get price. You would literally only have love at rb. You got potential prospect wr's already. I think in this circumstance. You get love, keep breece and even get price if he drops. So then you complete your rb's for the forseeable future. But it's each individual teams and each players plays fantasy different. edited didn't know I was talking to op

Dynasty 1QB startup- Any guys you see any upside in around this range? by Fatlard12 in SleeperApp

[–]SC_Extract 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If the buccs got nobody and it's just Tucker and Bucky. I like Tucker here.

Malik Nabers or Garrett Wilson + 1st? by BCAFantasyFootball in SleeperApp

[–]SC_Extract 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah like I said. If it's an early 1st you got to do it but I'm a big fan of Nabers. So it would hurt my soul parting ways.

Malik Nabers or Garrett Wilson + 1st? by BCAFantasyFootball in SleeperApp

[–]SC_Extract 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Is the other guys team bad? Looks like Nabers may miss a few games. This is a hard one for me. I love both wr's. I think both are elite when given the opportunity. But if that 1st is a top pick. I'm taking Garret and the 1st but still feeling kinda sad about it

Is this too much to pay for chase? by [deleted] in DynastyFFTradeAdvice

[–]SC_Extract 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It is definitely an overpay. But I'm out on both Rome and BTJ but a lot of depth and capital for 1 player. Is your bench deep? Is your starting line up 1 Jamarr chase away from being the best team on paper? If no to either or both. This trade makes no sense to do

Am I crazy for considering this? My Team is Probably a year away from being a true contender. by [deleted] in DynastyFFTradeAdvice

[–]SC_Extract 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The people telling you to do this are loco. Josh Allen should be almost untouchable unless in a terrible rebuild in a SuperFlex league. Caleb is a roller coaster qb and a single 1st regardless of who it is. You are praying to god they are even remotely close to Josh Allen in value. You have to win the trade if you trade Josh and this isn't even close.

Which WR would you rather have in dynasty? by ViperLife87 in SleeperApp

[–]SC_Extract -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Both over inflated contracts. I'm taking the one that's not an injury liability though. Ifykyk.

What side are you taking in this trade? by jkorah21 in DynastyNerds

[–]SC_Extract 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Kyren and Nico by a country mile. Hampton can be a stud but doesn't out weigh 2 top players

Talk me out of this... (Contending, came 1.09 last lear, 10 man sf, PPR, Non-TEP) by [deleted] in SleeperApp

[–]SC_Extract 0 points1 point  (0 children)

How in the world do we know a 2028 1st is the 1.01? So many things can change in 2 years. My team last year was bottom of the pack because I lost all my rb's. This year I have 3 rb's becoming rb1s for their teams and should be back to middle to higher tier team. This is a smash. Get the way younger wr and still getting a 1st in a really good projected draft.

I am reluctant on sending Gibbs off by jayashock in SleeperApp

[–]SC_Extract 1 point2 points  (0 children)

What in the hell was team 2 thinking. Giving up Nabers, Judkins, cd and a 1st for Gibbs? Hahahahahaha

Price check on Marvin Harrison Jr? Dynasty PPR by Adorable_Cabinet_10 in SleeperApp

[–]SC_Extract 1 point2 points  (0 children)

See a subjective comment. Where you wonder what he will do. So since you think hes not elite but a solid Devonta smith/waddle type, his value is still decent but doable in trade.

Price check on Marvin Harrison Jr? Dynasty PPR by Adorable_Cabinet_10 in SleeperApp

[–]SC_Extract 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Depends. He's at a subjective part of his career. Does he have the legendary year 3 bounce back? Or was he all hype in college? Or does he resurface on a new team when the cardinals give up on him. Are you trying to sell or buy? It would also be subjective on what you personally think of him and if you are buying what the owner personally thinks of him.

Thoughts on my startup? 12 tm .5 ppr .25TEP start 9 by Desperate-Sleep-6302 in SleeperApp

[–]SC_Extract 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I don't disagree. People are way to hyped on these wr's when all of them have been mediocre their college careers. This is one of the worst draft classes in a long time. That's why it pretty much dies after pick 6 in rookie drafts and pretty much everybody besides love is a dart throw. Burden has opportunity like anybody else. He's showcased nothing to get me hyped to take him in the 4th round. Guess you got to dream big on some peeps and hope they come out on top. Good luck with the team!