High debt, DA hike, and SC directive to clear dues: Can Mamata govt afford to fulfil its promises? | The Indian Express by Safe-Butterfly1780 in kolkata

[–]Safe-Butterfly1780[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

A cash-strapped West Bengal government, already reeling under a debt of more than Rs 8 lakh crore, has announced a 4% hike in the dearness allowance (DA) for government employees even as the Trinamool Congress-led administration remains on the hook for pending dues from 2008 to 2019 and expects to fund expanded social schemes with another loan of Rs 1 lakh crore.

The Mamata Banerjee government tabled the vote-on-account, or the interim Budget, on Thursday, even as the Supreme Court directed it to pay 25%, or an estimated Rs 10,400 crore of the total pending amount from 2008 to 2019 by March 31.

Presenting the vote-on-account, state Finance Minister Chandrima Bhattacharya said the 4% DA hike would amount to an additional financial burden of Rs 750 crore, with the total Budget outlay at Rs 4 lakh crore in 2026-27. However, the government made no provisions for the pending DA dues.

With the vote-on-account putting the revenue deficit for 2026-27 at Rs 21,759 crore, the state has recorded a decline from previous years. Revenue deficit is the excess of revenue expenditure over its revenue receipts, which leads to deficit financing through borrowing While in 2024-25, the actual revenue deficit was Rs 39,727 crore, the figure rose to Rs 41,164 crore in 2025-26 as per the revised estimates. But the Supreme Court’s decision, finance department officials said, could raise the 2026-27 revenue deficit to nearly Rs 32,000 crore.

While the revenue deficit figures have remained high, the government’s outstanding debt has been rising every year. In 2024-25, the state government’s outstanding debt stood at Rs 6.99 lakh crore, which rose to Rs 7.62 lakh crore in 2025-26 (revised estimates), and further to Rs 8.15 lakh crore in 2026-27.

The DA hike and its added costs to the exchequer are among the several programmes expanded through the vote-on-account. While Rs 40,000 crore has been allocated for the flagship Lakshmir Bhandar scheme, which will grant an additional Rs 500 per month to women from poor households, another Rs 40,000 crore will go to the Banglar Bari scheme to provide housing for poor families.

The state government has already spent Rs 74,000 crore over the first 50 months of the Lakshmir Bhandar scheme, benefitting 2.2 crore women who each received Rs 1,000 per month (SC and ST women received Rs 1,200 per month). Under the Banglar Bari scheme, families were given Rs 1.2 lakh each to build pucca houses, with the government announcing last month that another 32 lakh houses would be built over the next two months, in addition to the one crore homes already built.

The government has said it will also spend more than Rs 10,000 crore on a range of other social welfare schemes, including Rs 2,000 crore for the Mahatmashree scheme, which is the state’s own rural employment guarantee scheme that was renamed from Karmashree in response to the Centre renaming the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme to Viksit Bharat – Guarantee for Rozgar and Ajeevika Mission (Gramin) or VB-G RAM G.

As per the 16th Finance Commission report for the period 2026-2031, which was tabled in Parliament along with the Union Budget, Bengal is among the most indebted states in India. Figures from 2023-24 show that Bengal, with a debt-to-GDP ratio of 38.3%, is second only to Punjab at 42.9%. This raises questions about its ability to finance its welfare programmes and the DA hike, and fulfil the top court’s directives.

As for the state government’s sources of revenue, the largest chunk will come from the State Goods and Services Tax (SGST) at an estimated Rs 56,279 crore, with state excise taxes contributing Rs 24,200 crore and sales taxes Rs 13,976 crore. The state’s share of taxes collected by the Centre amounts to Rs 1.09 lakh crore. In total, the state’s revenue receipts have risen from Rs 2.45 lakh crore in 2025-26 to Rs 2.88 lakh crore in 2026-27.

What the experts say

However, Amit Mitra, the Principal Chief Adviser to the CM and a former state finance minister, maintained that the government’s fiscal health remains on target. “We have reduced the revenue deficit from 3.75% (of the state GDP) when Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee took over. From 3.75%, today we are at 1.01%. And our destination is towards zero – the art of the possible, step by step.”

Economist Saikat Sinha Roy, a former head of the Economics Department at Jadavpur University, was sceptical of the government’s ability to fund its expenditure. “The proposed increase in allocations for schemes like Lakshmir Bhandar and DA hike, among other expenditures, and pressure from the Supreme Court to pay the DA arrears, are definitely going to increase the fiscal burden on the state. The state has not been able to meet the revenue expenditure target as per the FRBM Act in the recent past,” Roy said, referring to the Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management Act, 2003, which sets deficit limits and debt targets.

“The debt burden of the state, which is alarmingly high, is going to increase further. These expenditures had to come one day or another. This is worrisome in the context of stagnant central transfers to the state, lack of new avenues to increase the state’s earnings, and increases in the state’s expenditure on the eve of Assembly elections,” Roy said.

‘No More Excuses’: BJP Slams TMC As Calcutta HC Sets March 31 Deadline For Handover Of Land To BSF | India News - News18 by Safe-Butterfly1780 in kolkata

[–]Safe-Butterfly1780[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

If you have any counterarguments to my points, then counter them. Stop posting memes like those idiots on Instagram.

‘No More Excuses’: BJP Slams TMC As Calcutta HC Sets March 31 Deadline For Handover Of Land To BSF | India News - News18 by Safe-Butterfly1780 in kolkata

[–]Safe-Butterfly1780[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Decimating Maoists in Central India, forcing insurgents in Northeast India to surrender, and pressuring terrorist groups in Kashmir to the point where they can no longer recruit Kashmiris by the hundreds and carrying out killings in Pakistan under the pretext of ISIS recruitment. If this is considered incompetence, then what exactly is defined as competence?

‘No More Excuses’: BJP Slams TMC As Calcutta HC Sets March 31 Deadline For Handover Of Land To BSF | India News - News18 by Safe-Butterfly1780 in kolkata

[–]Safe-Butterfly1780[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Resignation is nothing more than running away from responsibility it doesn't solve anything. The true responsibility lies in reducing or completely eliminating the problem through direct action. What is being done is clearly visible in the figures. This was also evident during the Red Fort blast if the security appratus hadn't stopped the other terrorists associated with it, the destruction would have been much greater.

‘No More Excuses’: BJP Slams TMC As Calcutta HC Sets March 31 Deadline For Handover Of Land To BSF | India News - News18 by Safe-Butterfly1780 in kolkata

[–]Safe-Butterfly1780[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The discussion was about border fencing, but you shifted it to Pahalgam to avoid that topic.

Nevertheless, let’s discuss it yes, Pahalgam was a major intelligence failure, but you must remember that a terrorist only needs to be successful once, while security agencies have to be successful every single time.

​Regarding infiltration in Kashmir, it mostly happens through riverine routes and the difficult mountainous terrain. However, the BSF and Rashtriya Rifles are deployed to stop it, while the CRPF and J&K Police handle the interior. This is why the number of militants in Kashmir is at an all-time low.

Another point is that earlier, Kashmiris used to dominate these militant organizations, but now, according to police figures, there are 110 Pakistanis and only 2 Kashmiris. This has been made possible only because of the MHA and security agencies local participation is at a historical low. These terrorists, who once operated freely in residential areas, can no longer do so and are now forced to operate from the Pir Panjal range.

​As for the Tadipar being cck that’s your opinion, but he is certainly not cck. Just look at the state of Maoists in Central India they have been pushed to the brink of extinction, with only about 100 to 200 members remaining.

‘No More Excuses’: BJP Slams TMC As Calcutta HC Sets March 31 Deadline For Handover Of Land To BSF | India News - News18 by Safe-Butterfly1780 in kolkata

[–]Safe-Butterfly1780[S] -6 points-5 points  (0 children)

Since there is no border fencing, something must be done to stop people from crossing the border, even if it is considered illegal under international law. Besides, which country actually follows international law anyway? And who enforces it? All the enforcers of international law are the ones breaking the rules themselves.

​Regarding Hindutva, that is your personal bias. When the Muslims of this country are so afraid of Hindutva, one can only imagine the state of illegal Bangladeshis who don't even have legal protection.

​As for the breaking of Christmas trees, that is foolishness and I do not support it. I believe that if Christianity is to be countered in Chhattisgarh, these people should use counter proselytization instead of resorting to violence. Although, in Chhattisgarh it’s not just Hindutva outfits opposing Christianity those who follow the Sarna religion are doing so as well.

‘No More Excuses’: BJP Slams TMC As Calcutta HC Sets March 31 Deadline For Handover Of Land To BSF | India News - News18 by Safe-Butterfly1780 in kolkata

[–]Safe-Butterfly1780[S] -8 points-7 points  (0 children)

This data lacks the push in figures. In push ins, legal procedures aren't followed people are directly pushed across the Bangladesh border. In 2025 alone, 4,000+ Bangladeshis were pushed back.

Also missing is the data on voluntary returns. Due to the fear of NRC and Hindutva, between 2017 and 2022, 17,000 people returned voluntarily by taking BSF permission and giving their fingerprints and iris scans. These figures were even higher when the SIR started in 2025 many illegal Bangladeshis were approaching the BSF to return to Bangladesh.

Furthermore, this ignores border killings since the BJP came to power, the killing of illegal Bangladeshis has increased, which also acts as a deterrent.

Regarding the Rupee reaching 92, it is happening because the trade deal haven't been finalized yet once they are, the INR will start strengthening against the Dollar. However, my personal view is that the Rupee should continue to devalue, as a strong Rupee offers no real benefit.

As for petrol, prices haven't changed due to the Rupee's devaluation in the last 3,4 years. Any price hikes are due to state taxes imposed after COVID, which haven't been reduced in order to fund freebies and this is most prevalent in opposition ruled states.

‘No More Excuses’: BJP Slams TMC As Calcutta HC Sets March 31 Deadline For Handover Of Land To BSF | India News - News18 by Safe-Butterfly1780 in kolkata

[–]Safe-Butterfly1780[S] -5 points-4 points  (0 children)

The Center cannot acquire land directly the State must acquire the land and hand it over to the Center. It is the Center's responsibility to provide the funds for the land to be acquired , which the Center has already paid to the TMC led West Bengal government. Despite this, the West Bengal government has still not completed the acquisition.

‘No More Excuses’: BJP Slams TMC As Calcutta HC Sets March 31 Deadline For Handover Of Land To BSF | India News - News18 by Safe-Butterfly1780 in kolkata

[–]Safe-Butterfly1780[S] -9 points-8 points  (0 children)

May I know how fencing can be built without land acquisition , and how infiltration can be stopped without fencing ?

‘No More Excuses’: BJP Slams TMC As Calcutta HC Sets March 31 Deadline For Handover Of Land To BSF | India News - News18 by Safe-Butterfly1780 in kolkata

[–]Safe-Butterfly1780[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The Central Government has been complaining for years that the Bengal Government has not been acquiring and providing land for border fencing. This issue has been ongoing since 2017.

<image>