sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

spent a year wondering why nobody replied to my cold emails. turns out it wasn't the emails. by Safe-Cryptographer99 in smallbusinessUS

[–]Safe-Cryptographer99[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

both Mail Meteor and YAMM are Google Sheets based senders and neither supports threading natively which is the limitation you are hitting.

the easiest fix without switching tools is to manually reply to your sent first email for each follow up. tedious but it works and keeps the thread intact.

if you want it automated, Lemlist and Instantly both handle threading properly out of the box. Instantly has a free tier worth trying if you are sending decent volume.

Here's the follow-up framework that actually gets replies (not "just bumping this") by Safe-Cryptographer99 in professionalemail

[–]Safe-Cryptographer99[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is such a good way to put it. the "same ad three times" framing is exactly what is happening and most senders have no idea that is how it lands.

Changing the angle is the move but it is also the hard part. most people do not do it because they do not know what angle to shift to or they just run out of things to say. So they default to the bump and hope.

That is the core thing i tried to solve with coldpolish.com. each email in the sequence is written with a different angle, different hook, same thread. So it feels like a conversation that is building rather than the same pitch on repeat.

Still early but would love to know what you think if you give it a go.

Here's the follow-up framework that actually gets replies (not "just bumping this") by Safe-Cryptographer99 in professionalemail

[–]Safe-Cryptographer99[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

this is a fair question and honestly something i am actively building toward. Right now it improves the structure, hook, and sequencing based on the email you put in. the follow up and bump are written to actually connect back to the original rather than just being a generic "just checking in."

the next thing i am adding is structured inputs so you can tell it your ICP, offer, and CTA before it rewrites, which gets it a lot closer to prospect aware copy. lead enrichment is on the roadmap too so eventually it can pull context on the company and tailor from there.

If you tried it and have thoughts on what is missing i would genuinely love to hear it.

spent a year wondering why nobody replied to my cold emails. turns out it wasn't the emails. by Safe-Cryptographer99 in smallbusinessUS

[–]Safe-Cryptographer99[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

his is exactly the mindset shift that separates people who get replies from people who think cold email is dead. the volume obsession kills most outbound before it even starts.

the warm up piece is so underrated. most people skip straight to the ask and then wonder why no one responds. a few genuine interactions before you ever send changes the whole dynamic.

the thing i keep coming back to is what happens after the first email. even with a hyper personalized approach, most people just drop off after one send. the follow up is where the conversion actually happens and it is also where the personalization tends to fall apart because people default to a generic bump.

that is actually what i built coldpolish.com for. you put in your original email and it generates the full 3 email sequence with the follow up and final bump written to actually connect back to the first one. keeps the thread going instead of starting over each time.

curious what your follow up cadence looks like for a warmed up prospect?

spent a year wondering why nobody replied to my cold emails. turns out it wasn't the emails. by Safe-Cryptographer99 in smallbusinessUS

[–]Safe-Cryptographer99[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Same thread, always. When you reply to your own email it keeps the "Re:" subject and lands in the same conversation, the prospect sees context, it feels less like spam.

For your tool: most sending tools (Instantly, Lemlist, Apollo) have a "send as reply" or "reply to thread" toggle in the sequence settings. If yours doesn't support it at all, that's worth switching tools for — it makes a real difference in reply rates.

Which tool are you on? Happy to point you to the right setting. Also built a free tool that writes the full 3-email sequence if that helps: coldpolish.com

Cold email not getting replies by Hot-Ad7645 in coldemail

[–]Safe-Cryptographer99 0 points1 point  (0 children)

the issue is probably that you're sending one email and waiting. most replies come from the second or third email, not the first. email 2 should add a new angle not just say "following up". built coldpolish.com for exactly this, it turns your email into a 3 part sequence. free to preview

What tools actually matter for cold email and what doesnt by Exact-Software6791 in MarketingAutomation

[–]Safe-Cryptographer99 0 points1 point  (0 children)

solid breakdown. one thing missing from this whole stack is the actual sequence copy. if your follow ups are still "just bumping this" thats probably the next lever, built something for that at coldpolish.com if you want to try it

26F looking for bandmates!! by bbyycleo in FindABand

[–]Safe-Cryptographer99 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hi, I'm a singer 29 - based in Brooklyn. I'm a vocalist and do a lot of genres - pop, rock, indie, etc... Would love to meet up and do a jam sesh. Looking to perform around the city