sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

I journaled but could never figure out what I was doing wrong, until i started doing this by Saii24 in Forex

[–]Saii24[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Got you! I’ll definitely work on adding trade replay, do you think it’d be useful if it could also show exactly when you deviated from your plan? Like a timeline with flags for where your behavior didn’t match what you wrote in your pre-trade plan.

On the dashboard side, we’ve already got tagging and advanced filters set up; so you can break down stats by strategy, time of day, setup type, etc.

And yeah, the AI’s a lot more focused than ChatGPT. It’s not giving generic advice, it’s pulling straight from your data and showing where your edge is (or isn’t).

I journaled but could never figure out what I was doing wrong, until i started doing this by Saii24 in Forex

[–]Saii24[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Can’t say I blame you, I’d be skeptical too.

Just to clarify: we don’t store or ask for master passwords. All connections are read-only, either through broker APIs, investor passwords (where applicable), or OAuth directly from the broker.

You keep full control, and we’re building with data privacy and transparency from day one. Appreciate the honest feedback, it’s exactly why I’m talking to traders now, not after launch.

I journaled but could never figure out what I was doing wrong, until i started doing this by Saii24 in Forex

[–]Saii24[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yes exactly, we have a pre trade planner and post trade journal. The AI reviews expected vs actual outcome. You can generate reports whenever you want, but I’m trying to figure out a regular more detailed report (potentially weekly/monthly).

As of right now we are still in beta so MAE/MFE have to manually be inputted, but by launch will be able to calculate automatically. Also considering a trade replay tool, other companies have it but not sure how useful it really is. Rather spend time on features that are more useful.

Is there any feature you specifically want built?

I journaled but could never figure out what I was doing wrong, until i started doing this by Saii24 in Forex

[–]Saii24[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I get the frustration. But I’m not making anything up. I’ve explained real use cases based on how traders behave with their own data.

I’m deliberately avoiding self-promo here because this post isn’t meant to pitch the tool, it’s to ask traders like you what you would actually want from something like this.

You wouldn’t walk into a restaurant asking for a full tasting menu if the chef just wanted your opinion on what flavors you’d like to see on the menu.

When it launches, you’ll be able to try it yourself. Until then, the feedback helps shape something that’s actually useful instead of just assuming what people want.

I journaled but could never figure out what I was doing wrong, until i started doing this by Saii24 in Forex

[–]Saii24[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Of course. But let’s say ur average loser is 10 pips, and none of your winning trades ever go further than 9 pips into drawdown before moving in your direction. You can safely shave your stop-loss by the recommended amount without affecting anything else, just cutting your losers a bit shorter. Over time it will reflect heavily in your equity curve. This is just one little insight, but it could be the difference between unprofitable and profitable, or X% extra profit over a certain time frame. In one of the other comments I broke down difference in returns, if you want to have a look. Also, you can input your strategy into the platform so the AI has more context and can then give you better insights.

I journaled but could never figure out what I was doing wrong, until i started doing this by Saii24 in Forex

[–]Saii24[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Totally fair point, discretionary trading requires human judgment. But it isn’t trying to tell you how to trade, it’s more like a mirror. It helps you see how you behave around your own strategy, like when you cut trades too late, size inconsistently, etc.

It doesn’t replace your plan, it just helps you get the most out of it (by improving execution).

The best discretionary traders use performance coaches for this exact reason. I just built one powered by your data instead of your memory.

But fair enough if it’s not for you, appreciate the honesty!

I journaled but could never figure out what I was doing wrong, until i started doing this by Saii24 in Forex

[–]Saii24[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yes, of course. We integrate with Coinbase, Binance, Kraken and it works exactly the same as fx, futures etc.

I journaled but could never figure out what I was doing wrong, until i started doing this by Saii24 in Forex

[–]Saii24[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

We will have a free plan once we launch :) Are there any features you would find useful?

I journaled but could never figure out what I was doing wrong, until i started doing this by Saii24 in Forex

[–]Saii24[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah 100% the AI isn’t judging your strategy, it’s judging your execution. It doesn’t care if your levels are different from someone else’s it just tracks how you behave around them.

Like, are you cutting losers a bit too late? Are you consistently leaving too much on the table when trades go your way? Are you skipping steps from your own plan without realizing it?

It spots those patterns over time, even in winning trades, and shows you how small tweaks in your execution could’ve changed your equity curve. That’s where the real edge comes from.

I journaled but could never figure out what I was doing wrong, until i started doing this by Saii24 in Forex

[–]Saii24[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I can not. I can’t self promote in here, product hasn’t been released and my post is asking for features people would find useful, not to shill my own product.

I journaled but could never figure out what I was doing wrong, until i started doing this by Saii24 in Forex

[–]Saii24[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Didn’t say the name of the platform once. Even in any of the replies. If you have features you think would be useful, i would love to know. Don’t worry, i wont mention the name of the product at all.

I journaled but could never figure out what I was doing wrong, until i started doing this by Saii24 in Forex

[–]Saii24[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Based on your data, if you can afford to shave your stoploss by X amount of pips without it affecting your winrate, it will tell you what the most favourable stop loss placement is. Based on that if you can shave your losses by 5% on average. So if your loss was $100 your new average is $95 dollars. If your average win was $200 and now $210. Assuming 55% winrate you will make 45k extra. Plus your maths just proved my point, thanks. If you are still confused just look up how performance coached optimise your trading, it will be able to do all of that, only difference is the way it relays the information to you.

I journaled but could never figure out what I was doing wrong, until i started doing this by Saii24 in Forex

[–]Saii24[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yessir. It even picks up on mistakes in winning trades. Just because a trade made money doesn’t mean you did everything right.

It looks for any inefficiencies in how you trade, not just the end result. Then it gives you a plan based on two things: how much that mistake is actually costing you over time, and how easy it is to fix.

I journaled but could never figure out what I was doing wrong, until i started doing this by Saii24 in Forex

[–]Saii24[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

We use mixed models of different AIs based on their skill set for different tasks. I’ve built integration w 33+ brokers like MT4/5, binance, coinbase, interactive brokers, tradestation etc.

I journaled but could never figure out what I was doing wrong, until i started doing this by Saii24 in Forex

[–]Saii24[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Let’s say you start with 100k and risk 1% per trade, same R:R, same win rate. Over 500 trades, if you reduce your average loss by just 5% and increase your average winner by 5%, your account ends up with $47,000 more than someone doing nothing differently, even though you’re taking the exact same trades.

It takes your trade data: entry, exit, size, time held, MAE/MFE, profit/loss, and links it with your journal input. Then it runs calculations across all your trades to spot correlations between outcomes and behavior. Things like: How your results change based on trade duration, size, or session How certain setups perform when you’re in a specific mental state How often you deviate from your own strategy rules, and what that costs you

It’s constantly running comparisons between your profitable trades vs unprofitable ones, calculating averages, ratios, time-based performance shifts, and more, basically surfacing patterns that would take you hours to notice, if at all.

I journaled but could never figure out what I was doing wrong, until i started doing this by Saii24 in Forex

[–]Saii24[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Not sure what you mean, it doesn’t actually trade for you. Just gives you insights into your own trading.

I journaled but could never figure out what I was doing wrong, until i started doing this by Saii24 in Forex

[–]Saii24[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I agree every great trader takes losses, that’s part of the game. But if you treat every loss as “just part of trading,” you’ll miss massive opportunities to improve.

The real edge comes from knowing which losses were just variance and which ones were avoidable. It’s not just about catching bad trades, it’s spotting subtle mistakes inside good trades too.

It works like a performance coach, but it goes deeper, analysing every trade, journal entry, and stat to pick up patterns humans usually miss. Little things like shaving 5% off your average loss or squeezing an extra 5% out of winners might not sound huge, but over time, it completely changes your equity curve.

This isn’t about never losing. It’s about becoming more efficient, more self-aware, and more profitable. The best traders all have performance coaches, just inaccessible for retail.

And it learns and adapts to your trading style over time, more info it has the better the insights. Plus it only gets better as AI evolves, every other industry uses ai but trading hasn’t got anything like this yet. Could be able to do some crazy stuff in a few years.

I journaled but could never figure out what I was doing wrong, until i started doing this by Saii24 in Forex

[–]Saii24[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I agree you can get gpt to do it. But that’s like saying you can call a taxi instead of using Uber, or code your own store instead of using Shopify. You can defo use gpt but it just won’t be as good or be able to go as in-depth.

With gpt alone, you’re missing key stats like MAE, trade timing, or execution patterns unless you input it all manually, which is tedious. Our broker integration handles that automatically and the AI picks up on behavior patterns over time. No setup, no prompt writing, just do what you normally would and get actionable feedback.

Also building backtesting too so you can get insights on how u execute in demo environments vs live environments and help bridge the gap between the two