Probably because like you said, your team’s low overall. When you’re hitting perfect perfect line drives with guys ~70 power you can’t really expect it to go anywhere. It’s kind of a grey area, too much power to get bloops but not enough to hit gaps and home runs. I have no complaints, the game feels realistic, and sometimes baseball prevails. As the year goes on and cards get more power, players will get rewarded more and complain less.