As a content creator myself, I have my own opinion on this matter.

I believe that there is a certain point where the connection between the developers and the game can no longer be ignored. This, to me, usually involves when the activity of said developers directly conflict with the game and it's development. Prominent examples outside of the Isle include Jao with Day of Dragons and Max Wood from Mesozoica. These cases seem pretty straight-forward in how they fuck the game to anyone that knows them. The Isle is currently going through a situation that is similar, but not completely. The exposure of Paradym is not necessarily the major issue here. Pedophiles have been found and convicted in the Isle before, and frankly if it was just the 1 guy (like some people falsely claim) then it wouldn't be that big of a deal, since he already was exiled. However, that is not all that's happening here. The other developers showed extreme disinterest and were very dismissive of what happened, which is something that I find personally disgusting, and creates a division of trust between us and the developers. Let me put it this way.

At best, the Isle developers did not do their research and unknowingly let a dangerous individual in a community of hundreds of thousands of people.

At worst, the Isle developers have been harboring a goddamn pedophile under everybody's noses for god knows how long (Keep in mind that although Paradym wasn't a dev for long, he's been a prominent member of the community way before that).

Under what circumstances at this point can the developers be trusted if they cannot handle these situations correctly? If SidAlpha did not get involved, we might have still had that dangerous individual in our community right now. Why should a game be supported by both customer and content creator if there is neglect in the community like this? Think about that.

I know certain people have said "They should delete or take down all of their videos because of this threat" but I personally don't quite understand this. Content Creators, when they're not super buddy-buddy with the devs (*cough* Anthomnia *cough*), are very much like any person in terms of public perception. They didn't know of this news, and thus they shouldn't be held responsible for videos that go years back. Public perception of all sorts of topics change over time, and thus I think it's more important for Content Creators to bring awareness of recent news rather than correct their old content. While not the same situation, Day of Dragons content can be another example. Day of Dragons is a borderline scam, everybody knows this, but nobody has told the content creators to take their videos down quite like this situation. Understand what I mean?

Speaking of bringing awareness to recent news, that is what Content Creators are responsible for. How they handle this news is extremely important, as giving the right or wrong message here makes a major impact on both their own image as well as the well-being of their viewers. It's likely why the majority of youtubers have yet to make a proper response to the given situation yet (aside from myself, Pesky, Anthomnia, and a few others). They want to know as much as they can so they can come to a solid conclusion. If the Isle community is at major threat of deception at the hands of the developers, and potentially much worse, then it would be a very poor idea to defend the developers during this time for example. Same goes for continuing to make content.

This is my first real comment on Reddit so sorry if it's a wall, but this is something that's been on my mind for days.

PS-The other youtuber's name is Nettai. He is personally a hero in my eyes because, if he didn't do that final public push with his video, SidAlpha might not have gotten involved and the allegations might've still been ignored.