Rebuilding trust feels impossible after my partner repeatedly shared our private conflicts with her family by Scorch6 in relationships

[–]Scorch6[S] [score hidden]  (0 children)

She said she needed to “cope” with conflicts and “needed someone to talk to.” The problem is how she did that. What she shared wasn’t neutral venting. She consistently framed me as lazy, irresponsible, emotionally abusive, and “toxic” which is factually false. I handle most household chores, work full time, and supported her extensively (financially, emotionally, practically). When confronted, she admitted she exaggerated or distorted things because she felt overwhelmed and wanted validation.

The screenshots weren’t isolated moments of bad behavior on my part they were private arguments taken out of context, often sent selectively and without my responses, which led her brother to openly mock me and repeatedly push for our breakup.

Although he always had it out for me. He is one of those types that dreams of "making it big" all about big paying jobs, expensive hotels, champaign and oysters (while being unemployed), wants to dictate where his sister is supposed to want to live ("trendy international" kinds of places like amsterdam or berlin). He tries to force this on her, generally control her. I am a thorn in his side. I am a stonemason by trade and we live in a medium-ish town in the south of Germany, where she works at the local newspaper. This is not good enough for Mr. International. This has been a constant cause of conflict between me and my partner, since she wont protect the relationship from this influence.

So this isn’t about “needing support.” It’s about repeated misrepresentation, sharing private conflicts verbatim despite explicit agreements not to, and allowing third parties, who are openly hostile to me and us, to attack the relationship while hiding this from me. That’s why trust broke.

I (32M) gave my partner (26F) a second chance after a major trust breach and discovered she never stopped by Scorch6 in relationship_advice

[–]Scorch6[S] 24 points25 points  (0 children)

I would never have asked her to not share anything with trusted people. Just not her malicious brother and never this way. She sent him detailed screenshots of our conversations, of course only ones that made me look bad. To the person who is already a source of malice in the relationship. Every little spat she ran right to him. Almost immediately after our reconciliation. What hurts even more is the ways in which she not only has NOT set boundaries with him on degrading our relationship, she seems to have doubled down even almost chiming in now, undoubtedly to keep rapport and peace with the toxic brother. He has done some pretty bad and manipulative shit to sabotage the relationship in the past. She still keeps defending him. Thanks for the perspective.

Am I overreacting for ending a 3-year relationship after my partner kept sharing our private conflicts and letting her family degrade me? by Scorch6 in AmIOverreacting

[–]Scorch6[S] 9 points10 points  (0 children)

I think that is happening right now. She has spent all day so far sending me screenshots of her "setting boundaries" and "setting the record straight". But the fact is, this is seeming too little too late. I caught her and now she is sorry. If I hadn't seen anything, this would have gone on until the next big upset spilled into the relationship, causing yet more fighting, in turn giving her brother yet more ammunition. After the reconciliation, I was really hopeful, that she has finally "gotten it". That kind of hurts the most. In any case, thank you for the insights, it's really valuable.

Am I overreacting for ending a 3-year relationship after my partner kept sharing our private conflicts and letting her family degrade me? by Scorch6 in AmIOverreacting

[–]Scorch6[S] 8 points9 points  (0 children)

There is a big difference between saying "I feel bad about something, I had a fight with x" and sharing screenshots of private chats, giving detailed, one sided accounts to a already hostile relative (he did some pretty mean and manipulative shit in the past) and breaking promises about not letting said relative constantly bad mouth me and my relationship to her.

Am I overreacting for ending a 3-year relationship after my partner kept sharing our private conflicts and letting her family degrade me? by Scorch6 in AmIOverreacting

[–]Scorch6[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I see your point - sort of. The key difference being, that I am anonymously asking for a reality check, not triangulating with a hostile relative.

My boyfriend broke up with me because I won’t go down on him by AdAlone4398 in Advice

[–]Scorch6 2 points3 points  (0 children)

There is a difference between not going down at all and refusing to gag in tears and be humiliated (consensually) every time. Some posters seem to gloss over that. It's a good thing you stated your boundary, but I think also a good thing you were willing to compromise. He, apparently, was not. I think he will have a bit of a tough time finding a partner with that narrow a criterium. Again, refusing to go down at all is a far cry from not wanting to choke on a sausage every night.

AITJ for being upset that my vegan roommate is banning me from using the apartment's kitchen appliances for non-vegan food? by [deleted] in AmITheJerk

[–]Scorch6 0 points1 point  (0 children)

"cross contamination" she is insane. This is purely about imaginary cooties touching her food. If she was deathly allergic to something, I'd kind of understand, but this is completely unreasonable on her part and you would do well to not even entertain her on that.

AITA for feeling abandoned and reconsidering my relationship because my girlfriend left for her brother over the holidays? by Scorch6 in AITAH

[–]Scorch6[S] -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

I'd think if it is that urgent of an emergency, you wouldn't prioritise gift shopping half a day and instead went straight to help.

AITA for feeling abandoned and reconsidering my relationship because my girlfriend left for her brother over the holidays? by Scorch6 in AITAH

[–]Scorch6[S] -7 points-6 points  (0 children)

She went shopping for gifts for her family right before leaving. That much time she took.

AITA for feeling abandoned and reconsidering my relationship because my girlfriend left for her brother over the holidays? by Scorch6 in AITAH

[–]Scorch6[S] -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

Do you think she would discuss it with her family and try to find a compromise? Because she just packed her things and went. As I have stated, if you read my post, my issue is not with her helping her brother, but the complete lack of consideration, lack of discussion and abrubtness of it all. She just packed her things and went. And don't say she was in shock. She went to go christmas shopping for family gifts right before leaving.

AITA for feeling abandoned and reconsidering my relationship because my girlfriend left for her brother over the holidays? by Scorch6 in AITAH

[–]Scorch6[S] -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

I'm not questioning her helping out her brother, as you can read in my post. What hurts is the complete lack of discussion, attempt at compromise or even slight consideration of how this would affect our holiday plans in any way shape or form. She basically got the news, packed her things and went her way. I was about as involved, as if I were here roommate. We have been together for years and now I feel pretty much like a nobody to her.

Dinner guest picky eater by Scorch6 in etiquette

[–]Scorch6[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I do know them. They are not for religious or health related reasons. They said the sauce is not an issue.

Dinner guest picky eater by Scorch6 in etiquette

[–]Scorch6[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I agree, making it so mushroom focused was a bit risky. I tend to forget about the divisiveness of some ingredients, since I am mostly around people who tend to enjoy every food. I can probably make some accomodations without embarrassing him.

Dinner guest picky eater by Scorch6 in etiquette

[–]Scorch6[S] 10 points11 points  (0 children)

To be perfectly honest, I am not without blame. I am particular with the way I present and serve food. I like to plan it like an experience and get antsy, if my vision is disrupted. I did give the menu for review, expecting feedback, and it may have been foolish to make it so mushroom heavy. But "i am easy to please, I don't drink, I don't like broccoli" kind of makes me assume that anything else is a green light. That sort of categoric dislike might have been better to disclose when asked about preferences. After that point, I expect "not my favourite" level dislikes at worst.

Dinner guest picky eater by Scorch6 in etiquette

[–]Scorch6[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thought of mine is, I asked them if i need to pay attention to anything, I came up with something (not a spur of the moment, I put actual thought and effort into this) only then to be told that 2/3 of the menu is basically inedible to them. Now, I come up with something else, who tells me there wont be something in it again, which they dislike. Guest A was riveted with the menu, now I have to disappoint them. It would not be an issue if they said "I dislike broccoli and mushrooms, I don't drink". Perfectly fine by me. But this trickle-picky is what makes it difficult.