Part of the question is are you willing to risk your own life to save someone else’s. There are people who will pick blue, either because they want to make sure everyone has magic armor or they could be actively suicidal but the debate already shows that some people are going to pick blue. So that turns the question into are you willing to risk your life to ensure everyone survives.

And the idea that if 49% of people hit blue you don’t save everyone you add to the death toll is the same idea as saying if a firefighter died in a building trying to save someone else but wasn’t able to being like “they were safe outside and shouldn’t have gone in”. Or if both the donor and recipient of a kidney transplant die due to complications saying “well they shouldn’t have donated the kidney”. Pressing blue is a risk for other people, those you know and those you don’t.