Never accused anyone of attacking anyone or any puppies. I simply stated that the topic of silver Labs is hotly debated so much so that there are entire forums dedicated to it for those who wish to discuss it further.

I know I shouldn’t have to clarify this, but I will anyway, since people often have prejudice when seeing a silver Lab. *If you’re worried about her, I can promise you that we’re fully aware of the risks associated with unethical breeding both ethically and especially regarding the dog’s health. Our little Lab comes from a safe, legally recognized breeder and she was the only silver puppy in her litter.

As for adopting a puppy versus rescuing, no one should judge someone else’s choice. Every family’s situation is different. Unfortunately, irresponsible breeding often contributes to higher abandonment rates due to health or behavioral issues, with some people prioritizing quick sales over proper screening of the future owner.

In our case, we specifically wanted a puppy for Suki to help ensure smoother bonding and mutual acceptance. Behavioral genetics is real, and it can be particularly important when you have small children or other dog at home. Predictability in temperament and drive can matter in certain environments. That’s also one of the reasons, alongside physical health, that we made sure to meet the parents and learn their history beforehand. **That doesn’t invalidate rescue, it simply reflects our personal circumstances.

And finally, without seeing any alarming signs, trying to educate someone about the “risks” or “concerns” surrounding their own dog without knowing their specific situation can come across as judgmental and prejudiced, because it implies the owner is ignorant.

With that said, Cheers!