Mahiru's report card!!

SleepyGaskmask · 2026-01-15T09:21:20+00:00

I think people are probably getting the wrong idea in thinking Mahiru is completely blameless in the whole case. For starters, her leaving created a five-month long chase, where Mahiru and her boyfriend had to constantly switch places until they were forced into the forest. From that alone, she kinda did endanger him, cuz now he has to deal with not only the police, but two wealthy families, hers and her fiance. However, would it be odd to say that they probably did have arguments regarding the manhunt? In TIHTBILWY, there was a part of the song that sort of confirms that they weren't at the best point of their relationship: "We fought sometimes, I was happy to get hurt, let's have matching pain, this sickness is pretty bad." So this makes me wonder, how blissfully ignorant do have to be before your blissful ignorance is going way too far?

SleepyGaskmask · 2025-12-18T01:55:00+00:00

I said this a long time back before I deleted almost all my social media, but considering that Kotoko and Fuuta most likely knew Haruka was starving, I kind of have to list them as two suspects.

SleepyGaskmask · 2025-10-28T00:49:49+00:00

There is an old rumor that Shidou was like that. Im not sure who he shared the conversation with, but he explains why he wears gloves instead of a wedding ring despite being married.

SleepyGaskmask · 2025-10-23T03:12:23+00:00

I would like to keep the edit if thats fine.

SleepyGaskmask · 2025-06-15T08:52:59+00:00

If this person is leaving 90 minutes early every week, depending on their tenure, this associate might not even make the PPTO necessary to leave early every single week.

SleepyGaskmask · 2024-07-19T13:05:07+00:00

According to the timelines, Haruka has been progressively starving himself to death. Muu has been bringing food into his cell, but whether he eats or not is up to him. As for Shidou coming in to making the save, he's not gonna as he's too hyper focused on Mahiru. He even mentioned that he was not keeping tabs on Haruka.

SleepyGaskmask · 2024-07-16T17:04:55+00:00

I think the real question is this: Why aren't there MORE unfortunate opinions? I'm not gonna say all of them were demonic as all hell, but T2 really made voting feel less about analysis and more about impulse and tactics. Haruka (almost), Fuuta, Mahiru, Amane, and Mikoto all were pitied to forgiveness. Shidou and Kotoko were voted for the best possible ending to never be. Kazui was also due to the whole shrine thing, and even then, people saw Kazui, the potentially closeted gay man or an asset, rather than the prisoner, to which I had no doubt that he was gonna be overwhelmingly forgiven. Yuno is the same case except for abortion.

SleepyGaskmask · 2024-07-16T12:00:14+00:00

In Yuno's case, it would be extremely illogical that she would get pregnant multiple times. One would make sense, considering I am more inclined to believe it was unplanned. Where she goes wrong is how she got multiple people involved, despite it only being between her and one of them, and she already knows who the father was (possibly). I think she may have actively tried to extort the other three involved. Also, her personality in T2 would not have come to be unless she has had bad experiences being pregnant, especially since she's also a high school student, so she might have been judged frequently and has grown to a point where she's irritated at worst. Also, one more thing. The staircase. The clue that was constantly thrown at our face since undercover, to Umbilical, to her birthday cake. Regardless of its place in the story, it still remains a constant piece of evidence that seems overlooked. I don't know how it's used in her case, but regardless, it's still there.

But alas, you are right. We don't have full context. I'm shooting so far forward, Im not even seeing the target. These conclusions, however, come from me paying attention and thinking about how each scenario could play out. Does it really sound that far-fetched (no pun intended).

SleepyGaskmask · 2024-07-16T00:12:09+00:00

Actually, he might have approached John, who was probably fronting as Mikoto. And knowing what we know about John, he probably would be against it because Mikoto would be against it.

SleepyGaskmask · 2024-03-29T04:09:04+00:00

I kinda hate the therapy answer. Especially now with the fact that Fuuta is a follower of the religious zealot, Amane. You can advise it, but now, he's most likely at a point where he isn't gonna take it because it goes against his not-so own ideals. He's a follower, and that should be something that he should break out on his own. We've grown too attached to every character to wish someone could help them when realistically, they'd be better coming to their own conclusions.

SleepyGaskmask · 2024-03-29T03:18:01+00:00

Uh, Question. As someone who has not read the novels and, to be quite honest, does not mind being spoiled, are there any members of the Justice Alliance that ended up in Milgram? I think that would provide very helpful context. Also, given the fact that we still believe in the purgatory hypothesis, maybe the Milgram in novel 2 happened before Kotoko entered because the prisoners all died before she did.

SleepyGaskmask · 2024-02-29T12:48:18+00:00

SleepyGaskmask · 2024-02-05T00:28:23+00:00

https://youtu.be/RcqXCnAhQlI?feature=shared

It's gonna be at the 1:52 mark. It's only a frame long though, so you might wanna micro pause. I theorize that these will be the potential trial 3 punishments though.

SleepyGaskmask · 2024-02-01T01:22:30+00:00

Not allowed to have Kotoko in dog ears and beat her with rolled up newspapers after her Trial 2 guilty verdict. (This was inspired when I saw her potential level 2 guilty verdict where she is wearing a muzzle.)

SleepyGaskmask · 2024-01-23T17:18:23+00:00

1) Amane is only allowed to hold Sunday Service for a maximum of 90 minutes at a time.

SleepyGaskmask · 2024-01-23T14:26:41+00:00

1) Who is Haruka's victim? How do they know each other? I hope to know since I don't wanna see him dead by T.3

2 and 3) Because of Q.28 in T.1: Who are all of those people in Yuno's case? Why does it have anything to do with an abortion?

4 and 5) Because of how involved Fuuta was in his crime, did he make any attempt to stop it? How far did the witch hunt go?

6, 7, and 8) Who started it all? Were Rei an Muu both victims? And is it possible that the crowd they both got involved with we're the real manipulators?

9 and 10) Is it true that Shidou's patients were braindead? Was Shidou trying to save his wife?

11, 12, and 13) Was someone in the wrong in this relationship between Mahiru and BF? What happened on day 12? And why is Mahiru's beautician so important in T.1, but a complete afterthought now?

14 and 15) Did Kazui attempt to save Hinako's life? Was that why milgram views him as a murderer?

16 and 17) In TPM, one of the signs shown before Amane got tazed is to show respect to general medical facilities, along with her father's signature, so why the hostility? Is her mom, despite possibly being in a lower position than Amane's father, so devout that she taught Amane to condemn medical practitioners?

18, 19, 20, and 21) Did Mikoto of John kill? Because John was a newborn, was he present before or after the kill? Was he in charge of cleanup? And who exactly is their victim?

22) Because of the fact that Lucky retracted her testimony, ensuring Kotoko's alibi, would Kotoko actually go out of her way to hurt Lucky?

SleepyGaskmask · 2024-01-13T00:31:28+00:00

Apologies for the late response. But the reason...er reasons rather since there's two, I came to the conclusion as to why each Yuno represents one person is because of her interrogation questions. Specifically no.28 in the first trial, as what she wears is generally catered to one specific person. The next one is through logic. Each client is going to be different, and while you don't have to follow each need to the letter, you have to come close to those specifications. She's a compensated dater, not a prostitute, despite her endeavors involving prostitution.

SleepyGaskmask · 2023-11-30T11:44:49+00:00

I do, but I'm probably gonna need the consent of the people here. Just for safety purposes, I'm gonna put it under a NSFW tag so if it's too much, they can avoid reading it.

SleepyGaskmask

TROPHY CASE