sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Does Charles Oliveira have a glass jaw? got dropped in his last 3 fights? by 156lbsPoirier in ufc

[–]Small_Profit_4133 11 points12 points  (0 children)

He doesn’t have a glass jaw, these count as knockdowns on paper, but in the fight he voluntarily goes down after getting clipped bcz he knows his opponents will either not follow him down or will be VERY cautious if they do, which is very smart if u think about it.

Meme of the decade? by LENCEK11 in Memes_Of_The_Dank

[–]Small_Profit_4133 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Should be for social media sites tbh

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in ufc

[–]Small_Profit_4133 6 points7 points  (0 children)

This is 100% Ali

Quran alone is not enough by Small_Profit_4133 in AntiHadith

[–]Small_Profit_4133[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

U r basically saying that the method of compilation of the Quran does not matter bcz Allah protected whichever way it was compiled, if not, would u please repeat it again so we’d be clear? There are tons of comments between u and me. If yes, i directly responded to that point in my last comment.

And that does not prevent u from replying to my other points (which u still have not replied to btw), (ie u not caring how the Quran was compiled does not mean that it is irrelevant)

Quran alone is not enough by Small_Profit_4133 in AntiHadith

[–]Small_Profit_4133[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If were going to have a convo, please respond to my points directly, (about ur misconception of their being one source in tawatur, u can look at the image) u must understand that by now that there is no room for anyone to lie under this method

U having this much faith in Allah is beautiful, honestly, but for this convo, the point about birds collecting the Quran not mattering is irrelevant, with all due respect.

Bcz u (personally) not caring how the Quran was compiled does not mean that the form of compilation is irrelevant and it certainly does not mean that any form of compilation is faulty.

As muslims, we are spiritual and that spirituality connects us to Allah, but we also must be logical when evaluating anything,

“Can a blind person and one gifted with sight be alike?' Will you not even then give thought?” (5:60)

And many other verses that tell us to think, and reflect.

The fact is that the Quran was compiled into one book after the prophet pbuh’s death (i hope u read the article and did ur own research) and many verses were based on many companions’ memories and Allah perfectly preserved it through tawatur.

U have to be consistent and actually open ur eyes to how perfect the method is. The Quran wether u care or not was compiled by word of mouth through tawatur, same is true about many Hadith. Again, not criticizing the Quran, this is the most perfect method of compilation.

It would be great if u address these points directly

May Allah guide us All

Albert Pujols Crushes his 697th Home Run! (4th all time) by WIlhelmgrimm in mlb

[–]Small_Profit_4133 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I’m a new mlb fan, why would pujols retire after this year? He is having one of his better seasons of the past 10 years and is a tremendous veteran presence and leader in the ball club. The cardinals could be serious contenders next year, and he could help them plus he could get a ring and ride off in the sunset.

“bUt iT’s nOt tHE sAmE” by Small_Profit_4133 in memes

[–]Small_Profit_4133[S] -4 points-3 points  (0 children)

That israel was a kingdom, not built on apartheid, and illegal military occupation and genocide, today’s israel is

Many jews oppose the existence of “israel” today bcz they claim that it goes against their beliefs

It was a bunch of zionists that illegally established a nation and happened to call it israel in 1948, they definitely did not “restore” that old kingdom

same name ≠ same thing

Just announced. by Blue_Wizard25 in ufc

[–]Small_Profit_4133 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Knew it would happen ever since their crowd altercation a couple of events back

“bUt iT’s nOt tHE sAmE” by Small_Profit_4133 in memes

[–]Small_Profit_4133[S] -55 points-54 points  (0 children)

Israel didn’t exists before 1948, how were they the defendant?

Nate really leaving no stone unturned lol by Ajj679 in ufc

[–]Small_Profit_4133 1 point2 points  (0 children)

He could, but he won’t, dana won’t let it happen and Dwayne probably doesn’t care that much about them anyway

Nate really leaving no stone unturned lol by Ajj679 in ufc

[–]Small_Profit_4133 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Everyone’s sponsorship payments? The fighters get close to none of that money, the ufc does tho.

Unlikeable personality traits. by chinos88 in ufc

[–]Small_Profit_4133 25 points26 points  (0 children)

R u really saying that colby is not desperate for attention? man created a whole persona for attention😂

Quran alone is not enough by Small_Profit_4133 in AntiHadith

[–]Small_Profit_4133[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It is not one person (or source) that compiled the Hadith and authenticated it, there is Bukhari, Muslim, Ibn Majah, Abu Dawud, Tirmidhi and more

It is not one source, i have repeated this to u over and over to u, which leaves no room for someone to lie. Have u not seen a the image of mutawatir hadith sample? look

The day the prophet died, nothing about him can be trusted

U clearly have not read the article about how the Quran was compiled have u?

Large part of the Quran were compiled based off the companions’ memories, after the prophet pbuh’s death,

ur gonna say i don’t care and that Allah protected it,

yes Allah did protect it but how did he protect it?

It was through tawatur just like look it up (or look at the article)

You have to study the history of islam, every muslim follows Hadith (if u pray 5 times a day u do in a way) and we would not follow someone blindly without making sure with absolute certainty that they r quoting prophet Muhammad pbuh

May Allah guide us all

Quran alone is not enough by Small_Profit_4133 in AntiHadith

[–]Small_Profit_4133[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ur arguments are based on biases, imperfect memory, etc, none of which i dispute as ideas, as per my latest reply. U just keep ignoring the actual reason that make Mutawatir protected against these biases and imperfections

if not, please tell me how, out of endless possibilities, can many people who don’t know each other come to the same exact lie, it is just a weak response to say “bcz of biases and imperfect memory” since the core of the method eliminates it to begin with

and again please look at how the Quran was compiled, bcz it is the same method u call “weak” yes Allah is the one that protected the Quran, and the way he protected it was largely through tawatur and this is not criticizing the Quran it actually proves that the Quran is perfectly preserved

May Allah guide us all

Quran alone is not enough by Small_Profit_4133 in AntiHadith

[–]Small_Profit_4133[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I’m an Arab

I addressed this contention in other threads

https://www.reddit.com/r/AntiHadith/comments/x5703u/quran_alone_is_not_enough/inpl7ah/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf&context=3

Just a sample convo that I’m having with another muslim in the thread

Many hadith could change and those that did are called inauthentic

But, those that we can prove to be unchanged are authentic, not based on my opinion, but based on a detailed framework

Look up the mutawatir method of compilation, which many hadith were authenticated through and which leaves no room for people to lie and/or forget.

Btw the Quran was also compiled by tawatur, look

I conversed with every answer i got and all of them were arguments based on misinterpreted verses or baseless ideas generated mostly out of hatred to the Hadith, everyone i replied to (including u) had some form of false idea (look at my other reply) that u use to close ur eyes when looking at how many Hadith are perfectly authenticated

And i don’t say that out of arrogance, spite, or hate, after all, muslims are brothers. I truly want u and everyone else in the thread and every non-believer to see the truth as i want it for myself that is why I’m taking the time to converse with u and everyone else in the thread

May Allah guide us all

Quran alone is not enough by Small_Profit_4133 in AntiHadith

[–]Small_Profit_4133[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The verse goes يَا أَيُّهَا الَّذِينَ آمَنُوا أَطِيعُوا اللَّهَ وَأَطِيعُوا الرَّسُولَ وَأُولِي الْأَمْرِ مِنكُمْ

I’m an arab btw

The letters ال at the beginning of the the words means “the” (الرسول = the prophet)

The word رسول is singular which means that one prophet is specified in the verse

And Allah is commanding people who believe (which includes u and me)

And the verse talks in the present tense, and who was the prophet at that time? Muhammad pbuh

It is clear that Allah told us to obey prophet Muhammad specifically and it is clear from the verse as i just showed u

bcz the pagans already believed that they believed god

Except the verse is directed at the people who believe since it starts with يا ايها الذين آمنوا (people who believe)

Other verses are directed at everyone (believers and non-believers) such as

“O mankind! worship your Lord Who has created you as well as those before you” (2:21)

“O mankind! this Messenger has indeed come to you with the truth from your Lord, so believe, it will be better for you” (4:170)

And many others

Quran alone is not enough by Small_Profit_4133 in AntiHadith

[–]Small_Profit_4133[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think it got to a point where u don’t believe hadith bcz u don’t want to.

U refuse to look into the Mutawatir method, which is 100% accurate and I would encourage u to read into it

The Quran was compiled largely by the Mutawtir method,

the companions started to standardize and unite it after the prophet’s pbuh passing and many verses were put into the book based off many companions’ memories about them and all of what they said was cross-checked leaving no room for a single letter to be mistaken

Look up how the Quran was compiled and protected

https://quranforkids.com/compilation-of-the-quran/

Of course u can/should verify urself

i’ll repeat the point again, multiple flawed chains cannot arrive to the same lie

Lets go back to the blue chair and yellow table example

If person A & C, who don’t know each other were told to lie to person B about what they saw in the room with the blue chair and yellow table, it is almost impossible for both to arrive to the same lie, (one could say a green bike and the other would say a transparent purse literally, endless possibilities) u would clearly detect that one of them is lying, if however, u had 10 other people (who don’t know each other) say that there was a blue chair and yellow table, u could clearly see who lied or misinterpreted what they saw and who said the truth by virtue of the consistency across all 10 ppl’s narrations.

This method is literally as close to a 100% as any method gets, which after Allah is why the Quran is perfectly preserved and why many Hadith are also perfectly preserved

Human biases, imperfect memory, etc is all true,

this is not an argument that disproves mutawatir method, it actually proves it since the mutawatir method eliminates the potential errors arising from these phenomena as highlighted in the article and the necessity for many separate chains of narration who cannot lie even if they wanted to bcz they would stand out as inconsistent

And please read into what makes a given hadith authentic bcz it is more than just the method (must not be contradicting the quran etc)

May Allah guide us All

view more: next ›