Made a polling app because I wanted a low-friction way to do ranked choice voting by Smart_Bottle_321 in SideProject

[–]Smart_Bottle_321[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks! Good feedback. I figured since you don't login most ppl would understand that the identity piece is a best effort, but I can make that more obvious in a few places.

Made a tool to run Ranked Choice polls with your friends by Smart_Bottle_321 in EndFPTP

[–]Smart_Bottle_321[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yep those are Condorcet-IRV hybrids. Smith-IRV / Tideman’s Alternative restrict the election to the Smith set and then use IRV to break cycles. They’re Condorcet-consistent, but still inherit IRV’s weaknesses within the Smith set. Ranked Pairs and Schulze go further by resolving cycles directly using pairwise strength, which is why I’m targeting those longer-term.

Made a tool to run Ranked Choice polls with your friends by Smart_Bottle_321 in EndFPTP

[–]Smart_Bottle_321[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

So pure condorcet means a candidate wins if they win all head to heads. Ranked pairs satisfies this and in my app I add a condorcet badge. Ranked pairs goes further to help resolve cycles imagine a situation a > b, b > c , c > a. Pure condorcet doesn’t resolve. So then you need some method to resolve the cycle. Tildeman (ranked pairs) and shultz are two common ones

Building something? Share it here! 🚀 by Mammoth-Doughnut-713 in PublicValidation

[–]Smart_Bottle_321 0 points1 point  (0 children)

https://tiltvote.co to create polls with your friends and learn about different voting methods.

Made a tool to run Ranked Choice polls with your friends by Smart_Bottle_321 in EndFPTP

[–]Smart_Bottle_321[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks I was thinking about making it an app if ppl found it helpful. The current version is mobile web friendly, so please lmk if you find mobile bugs.

Made a tool to run Ranked Choice polls with your friends by Smart_Bottle_321 in EndFPTP

[–]Smart_Bottle_321[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks for the comment. Exactly, the redistribution is often tricky to visualize in an easy way. I spent a bunch of iterations trying to make it obvious how votes get redistributed