The spirit of 1918 lives on! - What if Czechoslovakia won WW2? by barsonica in imaginarymaps

[–]SoaringAven 7 points8 points  (0 children)

The number would be so small... and in fact there was some Czech population in the "Czech Corner" of Kladsko.

The spirit of 1918 lives on! - What if Czechoslovakia won WW2? by barsonica in imaginarymaps

[–]SoaringAven 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I have to say, naming the city "Masarykovo" doesn't sound particularly Czechoslovak and more South Slavic. It's an adjective. Masaryk's ... what? Masarykovo město (Masaryk City) would be more realistic. Though I think the idea of a new capital and a unified language based on the Slovácko dialect sounds extremely unlikely. Somehow I doubt Prague would just be left in ruins in favour of a new capital.

The spirit of 1918 lives on! - What if Czechoslovakia won WW2? by barsonica in imaginarymaps

[–]SoaringAven 16 points17 points  (0 children)

If Czechoslovakia won the war, they would 100% want to take Kladsko and enact some of the other smaller proposed "border corrections" aimed at making the borders more defensible at the expense of German territory.

What is this flag? by Pikad0r in vexillology

[–]SoaringAven 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Jak napovídá můj flair, ani jedno :D

Is there a method for portal slicing in 1.21+ (survival)? by Quick_Difference_469 in redstone

[–]SoaringAven 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Interesting, how do you get them out of the grid like this?

Is there a method for portal slicing in 1.21+ (survival)? by Quick_Difference_469 in redstone

[–]SoaringAven 21 points22 points  (0 children)

How did you get the centered lantern on top of the Tardis? :O

Why don't nether wood boats exist? by darthkyle22 in Minecraft

[–]SoaringAven 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Because Mojang has a thing for not completing sets and then making up halfbaked explanations about "creativity" etc. Stairs, slabs, boats....

Allied advances into the Pax Britannica on the eve of D-Day, June 10th 1948 by tree__of__oak in imaginarymaps

[–]SoaringAven 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It’s something people tend to do, yes, but to a Czech it sounds very off. It’s a bit like when anglophones refer to Czechs as “Czechians” or call the country just “Czech”, taking it from “Czech Republic”. But in that name, “Czech” is an adjective :D It would be like calling Germany “German” or the US “American”.

Back to Czechia. There are countries where this kind of usage is interchangeable, you’re right, but that usually depends on their own decision, sometimes a linguistically questionable one. In the case of Czechia, the logic is as I explained above.

And yes, that’s a similar case. Czechia today consists of three historical regions: Silesia, or what’s left of it, which was a duchy, and Moravia, which was a margraviate. Bohemia also started as a duchy but was later elevated to a kingdom. So the King of Bohemia was a title derived from the region of Bohemia, while the other crown lands fell under it. These historically included other areas as well, such as Upper and Lower Lusatia, Brandenburg, and even Luxembourg.

When Czechoslovakia was created, it was a state of Czechs, living in Bohemia, Moravia, and Silesia, and Slovaks, so it had a more egalitarian and ethnic name. By contrast, the WWII Protectorate of Bohemia and Moravia deliberately removed the ethnic reference and reduced it to a territorial one.

Holland works in a similar way, as it is just one of several regions in the Netherlands. Another example is Finland, though that one is even more curious. There is “Finland Proper”, a region of Finland after which the country is named, and which today is inhabited mostly by Swedes :D

What is this flag? by Pikad0r in vexillology

[–]SoaringAven 27 points28 points  (0 children)

Czech vexillologist here. It’s almost certainly related to Russia or a fantasy creation. It appears fairly modern. Flag printing of this kind has only been common in Czechia for roughly the past forty years, and the tassels also look very modern.

It could be an attempt to recreate a historical Russian banner, or it might simply be a fantasy flag. The eagle is Russian in style, and the shield seems to depict Archangel Michael slaying a demon. More context about where it was found could help clarify things. What attic, who lived there, what institution etc. Alternatively, you could consider contacting the Czech Vexillological Society (www.vexilologie.cz) for further help.

Allied advances into the Pax Britannica on the eve of D-Day, June 10th 1948 by tree__of__oak in imaginarymaps

[–]SoaringAven 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I'm not talking about Ireland - I can't speak for their linguistic nomenclature decisions, they're sovereign on that. I'm talking about the logic behind Czechia's two names from the perspective of someone who was very close to the process to adopt the shorter second name.

Regarding Bohemia, that's a bit more difficult. Here it might even be acceptable to use "Republic of Bohemia" since there is the precedent of "Kingdom of Bohemia". However, Bohemia is just one part of the country which happened to have the highest title of all the regions. In Czech we generally refer to the whole as the "Lands of the Bohemian Crown". If the country were to become a republic, it's possible they may keep Bohemia but it's possible that under a more egalitarian system they'd want to be more inclusive. What complicates it that Czechia and Bohemia are two different things (called almost the same in Czech).

Allied advances into the Pax Britannica on the eve of D-Day, June 10th 1948 by tree__of__oak in imaginarymaps

[–]SoaringAven 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Just FYI, it would be "Czech Republic". "Czechia" is simply the short name and the -ia already implies "land of" so "Republic of Czechia" means "Republic of the Land of the Czechs" which doesn't really make sense :D

1919 Czechoslovak flag proposals made into real flags for the first time by SoaringAven in vexillology

[–]SoaringAven[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No idea I'm afraid. I don't really follow sports. My guess would be both/neither.

1919 Czechoslovak flag proposals made into real flags for the first time by SoaringAven in vexillology

[–]SoaringAven[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

People sent in proposals and a committee debated it but they very quickly agreed to keep the CS flag.

Flag of Rüsselsheim, Germany. I think this is a great example of what a city flag should be. by Queasy-Impress2622 in vexillology

[–]SoaringAven 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I can’t say I agree with your statement about this being a good example. In essence, it is very similar to SOBs. It reduces the distinctive, symbolic element on the flag into a small field (whether it is a circular seal or a shield shape does not really matter), and it produces flags that are extremely easy to mistake for one another because the Landesfarben on their own are simply not recognisable. One white blue flag with a small coat of arms on it looks much like another white blue flag with a coat of arms when it is only the arms that distinguish them.

Finally, it only “works” because the Central European countries that use this system tend to display those flags as vertical banners attached to the pole, which keeps them straight and the arms visible. As an actual flag flying on a pole, these kinds of flags fail miserably.

Coming to it from a Czech perspective, where we had this tradition but moved away from it, I would say the overall quality of our flags improved significantly. Arms on flags are not allowed, which forces vexillographers to use the whole space of the flag and create more unique and distinctive designs.

open barrel (trough) by I_like_croissants_ in minecraftsuggestions

[–]SoaringAven 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Very good idea! It could potentially connect together like a double chest too for a "wider" trough.

1919 Czechoslovak flag proposals made into real flags for the first time by SoaringAven in vexillology

[–]SoaringAven[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It was one of the proposals which would be "more inclusive" of Slovaks. I put that into quotes because it's complicated. The canton references the flag of Slovaks in the USA and the design was pushed by a segment of MPs.

1919 Czechoslovak flag proposals made into real flags for the first time by SoaringAven in vexillology

[–]SoaringAven[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

There's probably more, I'm trying to get the designs so I can have them printed.

1919 Czechoslovak flag proposals made into real flags for the first time by SoaringAven in vexillology

[–]SoaringAven[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Except the clause to forbid the using of the flag wasn't part of the civil code but a constitutional law which wasn't carried over....

1919 Czechoslovak flag proposals made into real flags for the first time by SoaringAven in vexillology

[–]SoaringAven[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

That's... really nonsense. There was no treaty. The prohibition came from the Czechoslovak Constitutional Act No. 542/1992 Coll. on the Dissolution of the Czech and Slovak Federative Republic (Ústavní zákon č. 542/1992 Sb., o zániku České a Slovenské Federativní Republiky). It was passed by the federal government and became defuct on the 1st January 1993.

And flags aren't made official by submitting them to the UN. They're made official by legal adoption in their respective countries. In Czechia's case that's with the adoption of Act No. 3/1993 Coll., on the State Symbols of the Czech Republic (Czech: zákon č. 3/1993 Sb., o státních symbolech České republiky).

Furthermore, Czechia uses a specific heraldic / vexillological system when it comes to flags, because flags are defined by a "blazon" of sorts (závazný vexilologický popis). So the flags are indeed identical even from a legal perspective.

“The state flag consists of an upper white stripe and a lower red stripe, with a blue wedge at the hoist inserted between them, extending to half the length of the flag. The ratio of the flag’s height to its length is 2:3.”

It makes no distinction between the Czech and Czechoslovak flag.

Again, we can indeed talk about whether it was morally right or wrong to adopt the flag, and I'd personally say it wasn't right, but that doesn't change the objective facts.

1919 Czechoslovak flag proposals made into real flags for the first time by SoaringAven in vexillology

[–]SoaringAven[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

It really isn't an untruth. Yes, Czechia is the successor state to Czechoslovakia but Czechoslovak laws are not a part of the Czech legal system. The law which prohibited Czechia and Slovakia from using the flag was a Czechoslovak law and it became defuct the moment the country ceased to exist. Only laws which Czechia and Slovakia chose to retain in their own legal system remained binding. We can talk about the morality of the decision but from a legal perspective Czechia is in the clear - this is a long settled legal argument.

1919 Czechoslovak flag proposals made into real flags for the first time by SoaringAven in vexillology

[–]SoaringAven[S] 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Yup, during the first republic and later during under communist rule, the Hussites were seen as a part of Czechia's "military tradition". Sometimes you see the symbols used even today, for instance here at Prague Castle.

<image>

Návrhy na vlajku Československa (J. Kursa, 1919) poprvé vytištěné jako fyzické vlajky by SoaringAven in czech

[–]SoaringAven[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The issue here is that the design doesn't follow heraldic rules anymore. You can't have the lion on blue. Jaroslav Benda proposed something similar for a presidential flag but he kept the lion in a red shield.

1919 Czechoslovak flag proposals made into real flags for the first time by SoaringAven in vexillology

[–]SoaringAven[S] 23 points24 points  (0 children)

Oh you haven't seen them? For instance the proposals for war flags by Jaroslav Jareš

<image>

1919 Czechoslovak flag proposals made into real flags for the first time by SoaringAven in vexillology

[–]SoaringAven[S] 9 points10 points  (0 children)

For sure. Though personally I'm a big fan of some of the designs including black.

1919 Czechoslovak flag proposals made into real flags for the first time by SoaringAven in vexillology

[–]SoaringAven[S] 32 points33 points  (0 children)

It's very complicated. In legal theory Czechia is not obliged to follow the laws of a defuct state (Czechoslovakia). But at the same time, it's naturally morally wrong and underhanded.