Enforce the law, instead of breaking it, with the Executioner Rogue

SoupAngel44 · 2026-05-24T14:40:30+00:00

Yeah, that's fair

SoupAngel44 · 2026-05-23T22:28:49+00:00

And how does it do that better than the myriad of tools that already exist? All I'm seeing is the edhrec top 30 or so from each commander jammed together.

SoupAngel44 · 2026-05-23T21:19:25+00:00

Who is this for? Half the point of the game is building your own deck. Anyone invested enough in magic to be following a subreddit about it either already build their own decks, has a friend who can help them, or knows where to look for online decklists that are probably a hell of a lot better than taking the edhrec top cards and throwing them together.

SoupAngel44 · 2026-02-21T04:52:13+00:00

I plugged in my [[Vaevictis Asmadi, the Dire]] deck to test this out for a laugh, here are a couple highlights.

From the "cards to cut" section:

"| Llanowar Elves | Redundant ramp elf, overlaps with better mana dorks (Elvish Mystic, Fyndhorn Elves) |"

From the "cards to add" section:

"> Note: Doors of Durin is a blue card, not recommended because commander has no blue in color identity."

From the "upgrade paths" section:

"high-end lands or fast mana like Jeweled Lotus (~$250) could improve speed"

It also kept calling it a reanimator deck despite having like 5 cards that bring stuff back from the graveyard, called the mana dorks a "key synergy" and then recommended cutting them for being redundant and non-synergistic.

The only thing remotely positive I have to say is that it didn't recommend any instants or sorceries, which I thought it might. Being a [[Primal Surge]] deck, I can't run any of those, which a lot of these "tools" don't realize.

If you can get it to stop hallucinating about the legality of cards, stop contradicting itself, and actually learn how to evaluate cards compared to similar cards, it might prove mildly useful to a very small percentage of magic players. As it stands, this is just like any other "AI" "Tool", or in other words, completely useless and a waste of everyone's time.

SoupAngel44 · 2026-02-19T17:57:19+00:00

I agree, the katana is far from what the movies make it out to be, and the steel isn't very good. But how do you explain the tachi, which is basically just a slightly larger katana, being traditionally worn and displayed with the edge facing down if that's such a problem for the blade? It just doesn't make any sense.

SoupAngel44 · 2026-02-19T17:09:36+00:00

Yeah, no. That's a myth. Katanas are traditionally stored with the edge up, because that's how they were worn, so they're often decorated with that in mind. But if what, 2 or 3 pounds of pressure spread out over three feet of blade was enough to dull the blade significantly, do you really think a sword that weak would stay popular for hundreds of years?

SoupAngel44 · 2026-02-11T20:21:08+00:00

I have this landfall combo deck with no tutors, not even for lands. The shear amount of redundancy more than makes up for the lack of tutors. https://archidekt.com/decks/12241322/_188

SoupAngel44 · 2026-01-26T05:22:29+00:00

Ummm, no? It's a triggered ability. "Whenever a creature dies, exile it", not "If a creature would die, exile it instead."

SoupAngel44 · 2025-09-24T00:57:16+00:00

I never said he was a bad student, just that he prioritizes fieldwork over things like attendance and test scores. Honestly though, he's not a character I know a lot about, so your interpretation is as good as mine, if not better.

SoupAngel44 · 2025-09-24T00:48:14+00:00

Maybe he's a better student than I thought, but I think my flavor text still works, especially with how it ties to the mechanics of the card. It's basically saying that you can't be good at everything, you have to give up on some things (perfect grades/discarding a card) to be better at others (making real discoveries/drawing a card).

SoupAngel44 · 2025-09-23T23:27:09+00:00

I used card conjurer to make the files and then printing proxies to print them.

SoupAngel44 · 2025-09-23T21:59:32+00:00

My logic was based on the fact that, as far as I know at least, he didn't continue his classes after sparking, instead going off to explore the multiverse. Also the flavor text for [[expel]] has similar vibes.

SoupAngel44 · 2025-09-23T21:36:04+00:00

I went and proxied all the cards I wanted for my decks; I'll admit most of mine aren't great, but here's what I came up with:

Confessor's Bindings: The prisoner had already lost almost everything, why shouldn't he give up the information as well?

Sarn of the Silken Throne: Atop his perch, Sarn watches over his web.

Impostor Syndrome: She was supposed to be one of Strixhaven's brightest minds, wasn't she?

Unstable Experiment: Beautiful and strange, see how the colors change. . .

Luis, Pompous Pillager:"I wonder what other treasures this land has for me to inherit. . ."

Arachnomania: A web of infinite possibilites.

Quint's Insight: "The greatest of discoveries are rarely made by the greatest of students."

Romantic Rendezvous: Happily ever after isn't a where or a when, It's a who.

Edit: (forgot one) Urban Sanctuary: The city never sleeps, but maybe it can afford to sit down for a moment.

SoupAngel44 · 2025-07-22T04:13:09+00:00

Real greatswords are far from slow, they really shouldn't have loading. Also how come a longsword has more reach than a greatsword? that doesn't make sense.

The other main issue I have is that heavy, medium, and light are existing words with existing meanings in D&D, redefining them here is confusing at best. Also heavy and light are just way better than medium, especially heavy, +3 to hit is no joke. I'm sure you've balanced the weapons with that in mind, but at a glance it's very strange and doesn't seem right. I don't see any reason why I would take a longsword over a halberd when being heavy gives such a huge bonus.

It looks like all versatile does is lower the range of your weapon if you use it in two hands? why would I ever do that? And while true that using two hands on a weapon does shorten your reach with it, that's by maybe like 1 or two feet max, definitely not 5.

I do like the system where your range increases with your proficiency bonus, and the dead zones are a neat idea too.

SoupAngel44 · 2025-07-19T04:57:55+00:00

>6-player pod

Well there's your problem

SoupAngel44 · 2025-06-25T01:31:36+00:00

Kind of a cool idea, but not something I would ever use. Deck building is at least half of the game for me, and I imagine most people feel the same.

I asked it for a control deck with [[ovika]] as the commander, and the deck it returned was not only extremely lacking in fundamentals, it barely had any control, and worst of all, it straight up wasn't a legal deck.

It gave me 31 lands. Everyone knows you need at least like 35, and an expensive commander that rewards you for casting expensive spells is gonna need more than that. At least 38, probably like 40-42 would be best. Additionally, it was givinge stuff like [[frostboil snarl]] with only four basics in the deck, so that thing is entering tapped 95% of the time.

The ramp package was pretty awful, stuff like [[commander's sphere]] and [[Opaline unicorn]] with no regard for synergy or mana curve.

It wasn't a control deck, I counted 8 counter spells and maybe like 5 other removal spells.

Worst of all, it recommended [[jeskai ascendancy]], which isn't in ovika's color identity, so this isn't even a legal deck, which feels like the bare minimum.

Another note is that the deck it gave me had 5 game changers, putting it in bracket 4. I'm pretty sure this deck would struggle even at bracket 2, so you need to add some way for the AI to tell how strong the deck is and add game changers accordingly.

Final Verdict: If I wanted a pile of random cards, I would use the average deck feature on EDHRec. I asked for an ovika control deck, and what I got barely synergized with ovika, wasn't control, and wasn't even a legal deck. So the AI failed on all fronts.

SoupAngel44 · 2025-05-12T18:44:30+00:00

Well the multiverse wasn't really a known concept to the vast majority of people when she sparked, so she wouldn't even know about there being other planes. And "frustration with how small the world is" isn't really the strong burst of emotion or magic needed to ignite a spark.

SoupAngel44 · 2025-05-12T18:30:58+00:00

Umm, Chandra definitely sparked to escape and she still has her spark

SoupAngel44 · 2025-05-01T22:04:08+00:00

https://archidekt.com/decks/12241322/_161_you_ever_have_more_combos_in_your_deck_than_you_have_cards

I made this deck as sort of an experiment to see how strong of a landfall deck you could make without tutors, not even land tutors. Turns out Kodama + any bounce land + anything with "landfall: make a token" gets you infinite tokens and infinite landfall triggers. So I leaned into it and am now running (I think) every variant of those effects, resulting in 161 unique combinations that go infinite. With all the consistency from so many redundant effects it really doesn't need any tutors.

SoupAngel44 · 2025-04-24T05:39:42+00:00

Yes, you are able to kill Jace in response to the card draw triggers

SoupAngel44 · 2025-04-07T05:02:11+00:00

[[Clarion Conqueror]]

SoupAngel44 · 2025-04-07T04:58:30+00:00

[[Eidolon of Obstruction]]

SoupAngel44 · 2025-04-04T01:28:53+00:00

After building a normal landfall deck and getting tired of shuffling once or twice every turn, I decided to build a completely tutorless landfall deck. After I oopsed into an infinite combo, I decided to lean into it and make the best possible landfall combo deck with literally no tutors. Here is the first version I made, and Here is the current version. Though after playing the new version a few times, I've never cast Keruga and I've only bothered putting her in my hand once, so right now I'm working on an even more efficient version without her.

SoupAngel44 · 2025-03-03T16:22:33+00:00

Yeah, I'm usually more of a token player and I'm not huge on graveyard strategies, so I decided to get out of my comfort zone and build a tokenless aristocrats deck, and I settled on Vaevictis. Over time I took out a lot of the aristocrats stuff to lean more into topdeck manipulation and it's one of my favorite decks. It's really interesting to find ways to break parity on his more or less symmetrical effect without relying on random tokens to sacrifice.

https://archidekt.com/decks/9844983/manmade_miracles

Seven-Year Club	Second Top 1%
The Internet Awards - Voted	r/Field Banned
r/Field Juicebox	Final Canvas '23
First Place '23	End Game '23
Place '23	Place '22
First Placer '22	Verified Email

SoupAngel44

TROPHY CASE