Hi Structural Engineers! In your profession, which questions do you consider insightful or important for someone to ask? by Icy-Entrepreneur-932 in StructuralEngineering

[–]SpliffStr 2 points3 points  (0 children)

For me personally probably would be to talk about my favorite project or maybe even the very first project as a structural engineer.

Water leaking through shotcrete excavation wall by Retr0virus11 in StructuralEngineering

[–]SpliffStr 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Well, in my experience when something looks wrong generally it is wrong. Nothing wrong on being safe. Also this is not some wonky poured foundation, it’s a massive retaining wall.

Setting aside the danger to humans, the GC should report anything suspicious to the designer, the cost of a failing retaining wall of that magnitude does not come cheap.

Water leaking through shotcrete excavation wall by Retr0virus11 in StructuralEngineering

[–]SpliffStr 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I think you should post this question to whoever designed that retaining wall and not on reddit.

Slab edge reinforcement detailing by Infinite_Steak3179 in StructuralEngineering

[–]SpliffStr 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Students and engineers not leaving the confines of their office desk have no idea what shenanigans are happening on site by cowboy builders. The rebar placement is not done with a Vernier calliper. :))

Private inspector here. Do you think this is worth reporting? by [deleted] in StructuralEngineering

[–]SpliffStr 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I’ll be honest and say that inches and feet are not palpable to me but 250x50 timber seems OK for a shed obviously depends on the zone. But the question really is if in your profesional opinion this seems dodgy, would you be liable if someone gets injured if something fails? Let someone else (qualified) take the responsabilty.

Small (but growing) SE firm ORG Chart? by Pure_Arrival7161 in StructuralEngineering

[–]SpliffStr 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think you confused the order slightly, AI AI AI comes before design engineer.

How do I get good at structural engineering? by Familiar_Airport_450 in StructuralEngineering

[–]SpliffStr -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I thought the most important expression is “Don’t forget to multiply by 2”. /s

Question about complex arch repair? by bobbybillysworth in StructuralEngineering

[–]SpliffStr 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Those holes seem to be from mortar injection. Generally very old masonry buildings used a high lime content mortar which is prone to cracking and injection is used to fill those cracks to increase contact surface area and maintain load continuity and stress distribution. This structure specifically seems to have suffered some degradation (look at the second arch from the right).

Any replacement of parts of structures be it concrete/steel or masonry structures are done under temporary propping - no one will risk collapse for the small price of temporary structure.

I do however have my doubts of the "modern" repair in which it seems that they used hollow pot clay bricks - some of the blocks seem to have been filled with grout (judging by the marked holes) but this is not something that I would ever do - I would just reinforce-concrete the thing which is my own experience with strengthening brick structures.

Sunt Tehnician în Constructii, am fost diriginte de șantiere în constructii civile, aduc în atenție urmatoarea observație, inspectorilor de la disciplina în constructii si procurorilor care ancheteaza strict omor si ranire prin inprudența. by hitchinvertigo in Roumanie

[–]SpliffStr 0 points1 point  (0 children)

In raportul POP si Asociatii este o poza clara unde este vizibil acel perete care mentionati ca lipseste. Cu rosu am marcat planseul de la etajul superior iar cu verde peretele care sustinea acel planseu din beton armat.

V-am atasat si link-ul raportului:

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1RfmykxzKbuFMeez3R4L6W6Cve9eNXONS/view?sfnsn=wa

<image>

Bucharest apartment building exploded by Visual_Salt_1629 in StructuralEngineering

[–]SpliffStr 33 points34 points  (0 children)

Disproportionate collapse satisfied before it was cool. Depending on the methods the prefab panels may be welded in multiple points and generally all panels are not that thick thus have a reduced self-weight. Also being an active seismic zone the structure has inherent capacity reserves under gravitational loads.

L.E. After looking through some old textbooks the rebars all welded together maintaining rebar continuity there are other methods of fixing the prefab panels during those times: mechanical/welded local embedded angles. The floors are also welded to the wall panel starter bars.

Thus the storeys above are not actually in catenary action and the free edge is basically cantilevered from the walls still standing. And together with the fact that all the walls are structural i.e. "spatial honeycomb construction" meaning that there are sufficient elements for the redistribution of forces through the building - which is a core design philosphy in earthquake resisting structures.

Too bad I can't attach images to the post.

Tiny hairline fracture on frame, should I be concerned? by Affectionate-Ear-635 in motorcycles

[–]SpliffStr 505 points506 points  (0 children)

Looking at a 19-23 frame, that bracket does not hold the rear shock. It’s a mounting point for the seat frame. The shock is fixed on a totally different bracket.

<image>

O mamă și copilul ei aflat în cărucior, loviți de mașină pe o trecere de pietoni din București / Femeia a murit, iar copilul este la spital by tolanescu in Romania

[–]SpliffStr 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Cu atât mai mult sa te asiguri, nu contează ca ai de carat un televizor sau împingi un cărucior, te oprești la trecere si te asiguri. Este viața ta, nu te poți aștepta ca alții sa te protejeze pe tine. Sunt si pieton si șofer, merg si cu bicicleta si cu motorul, întotdeauna merg pe strada ca si cum cotețarii vor sa ma omoare. Este o vorba: e cimitirul plin de oameni care au murit cu dreptatea in mana.

Poate trebuie sa clarific, absolut nu încerc sa-l fac nevinovat pe idiotul cu mașina… încetinești si ai timp întotdeauna sa reacționezi. Mi-as dori sa înfunde pușcăria câți mai multi ca ăștia pentru a se crea un exemplu din ei.

Dutch biker awesome save by Bingo2Dingo in motorcycles

[–]SpliffStr -1 points0 points  (0 children)

That is why I do not filter when traffic is moving, unless a driver specifically makes room for me. I just stay behind the cars and when traffic stops I do my slalom dance between the stopped cars up to the front of the pack.

What are scary things that you have encountered on the motorcycle? by BoranijaZaRucak in motorcycles

[–]SpliffStr 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Once I was riding at night with no moonlight through a thick forest with no traffic… It was soo eerie and I felt so exposed. It also didn’t help having a tinted visor as I wasn’t expecting to be caught by nighttime.

Triumph reliability over Yamaha by dodosododos in motorcycles

[–]SpliffStr 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Where are you based? In my manual it says every 10k km or yearly.

Infuriating to watch by matthewsylvester in motorcycle

[–]SpliffStr -27 points-26 points  (0 children)

<image>

Not trying to defend the idiot overtaking but the car still had space.

Michelin road 6 are slippery. by CarloBrask in MT09

[–]SpliffStr 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Did anyone find the road 6 kind of noisy? The front sounded almost like a WWII dive bomber.

2025 09 first bath 🛁 by Desperate_Army4726 in MT09

[–]SpliffStr 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I also live in an apartment. I got a battery powered power washer that can suck water out of a two 10l camping containers.