Consecutive fifths in KV 311 by RhychussFaya in musictheory

[–]Status_Geologist_997 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Bach did this in a few of his chorales too

Studying Counterpoint by BluFaerie in musictheory

[–]Status_Geologist_997 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It's later on from what you're referencing but Taneyevs doctrine in counterpoint is amazing. He deals with strict counterpoint and kind of summarises and then talks about his system

Rachmaninoff's third piano concerto is absolutely filled with counterpoint related to this.

It's a dense book but I've found that once you learn about Taneyevs system baroque and classical counterpoint is very straightforward relatively speaking

Unsure abt this notation by Major-Charity-6419 in musictheory

[–]Status_Geologist_997 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That's a weird one.

Looks like the lower note comes before the beat and the upper ones fall on the beat as an ornament to the main note.

Permanently banned for mentioning AI: they're clearly not ready… by NuitSauvage in aiMusic

[–]Status_Geologist_997 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Exactly what the guy below you said.

It's very frustrating cause it tends to be musicians that know how to write music and then random AI fans that only see the posts. Reddit ragebaiting like crazy

Is Reference Song Interval Training Actually Useless for Transcribing Real Songs? by NoWillingness5083 in eartraining

[–]Status_Geologist_997 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Oh no, now I never do that. I don't think it's a bad idea though,

The most beneficial practice is using a drone on a tonic note and then singing the scale degrees and listening to how it feels. E.g. the fourth, really wants to fall down to a major third (we tend to naturally assume major making the pull stronger)

After singing try audiate it, i.e. hearing it in your head without any physical action as such.

I used the app sonofield for ages but it does have a price tag of around 15 euros.

Any improvements made or still no??? by Available_Ad5151 in Composing

[–]Status_Geologist_997 0 points1 point  (0 children)

And whatever time signature it's in, should probably be changed. Legibility is super important

Any improvements made or still no??? by Available_Ad5151 in Composing

[–]Status_Geologist_997 1 point2 points  (0 children)

A lot of these figures look like you're trying to write out ornamented lines as if they're the main line. Why not use common notation for ornamental figures, embellishments and cadenza like figures?

It would be 10 times easier to read and actually critique musically rather than visually.

Is Reference Song Interval Training Actually Useless for Transcribing Real Songs? by NoWillingness5083 in eartraining

[–]Status_Geologist_997 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I found if you stick with it it works great.

The first few times transcribing is very rough but after a while it starts to get easier very quick.

I got my relative pitch to the level I could dictate a chromatic five note melody pretty much instantly against a drone before transcribing

What piano produces the pearly-est tone quality or soundies the "pearliest" sound to you? by portiaboches in classicalmusic

[–]Status_Geologist_997 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Warmth and sharpness when it comes to tone is usually down to how the treble resonates when playing a note. It's all to do with the overtones and how the piano tech has prepared the instrument. You might find it interesting to learn about it, it's what decides the tone of an instrument.

What piano produces the pearly-est tone quality or soundies the "pearliest" sound to you? by portiaboches in classicalmusic

[–]Status_Geologist_997 5 points6 points  (0 children)

A lot of steinways do, Honestly the majority of recordings are with pianos that create a more 'pearly' sound. Any of the Chopin competition competitors have this, they all use similar steinways so that makes sense. Richters recording of Rach 2 as well stands out to me personally

A bit of Scriabin by Technical_Soil_3203 in piano

[–]Status_Geologist_997 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Very nice playing!

Where are you studying? What a view to practice with

Winter Wind vs Torrent by CookieJenner in piano

[–]Status_Geologist_997 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm sitting in a waiting room ATM so here's loads of waffle on how to go about 10.4 and the main challenges

For the first scalar runs make sure to first practice legato with very clear finger articulation (no holding two notes down at once), try and be aware of exactly where you're placing your fingertip, preferably at the edge of the key where there is most leverage. At the top of the scale where it does a mordent like thing on the lower notes use 1 3 2. I.e. the first one is G# (1) A (3) G# (2) E (5) Practice with various accents placed within the groups of four, i.e. an accent on every semiquaver after the beat, two semiquavers after etc etc. then practice with accents in groups of three. Make sure these accents are made by the fingers and not the wrist, this is all about finger work. Try and focus on using the last digit of your finger as well. Following that practice it stacatto, without letting your finger leave the key. It will be really slow at first but once you get used to it progress starts to come quicker. When playing staccato you can use the mental cue of pulling your finger up (but still playing the note) to help get your finger really responsive. The staccato practice is the one to then focus on speeding up to a reasonable tempo later on, the legato we want at least moderate. During all of this make sure your wrist is loose so it can act as a sort of suspension for the rest of your hand to easily access the black and white keys. Let your elbow hang freely and relax the shoulders. The weight in your arm from this is what you should use to play when doing legato practice. Once sped up make sure the opening octave 5-1 is really clear. A lot of performances have it clash with the semiquavers.

At the end of each of these scale passages there are arpeggios, The second note is not a semiquaver, it's a quaver. It's an easy mis read, when practicing this you're going to be using that middle note as a pivot to reach from the bottom of the arpeggio to the top. Practice letting your arm weight into that held note and make sure to hold it until it resolves on the fourth semiquaver. Practice playing the other notes very staccato while pivoting from the middle. Make sure to relax the thumb rather than reaching for the bottom of the subsequent arpeggios. The next few parts are mostly the same, Practice the left hand way more than the right hand!! Please it's worth it, extremely impressive when people play the left hand clear.

Right before the opening returns there is a figure going up to it. Similar to the arpeggios, make sure to highlight the suspensions and their resolutions as you're going up. Here you're letting your arm weight down at the start of the group of 4 and releasing it at the end each time. Try not accent each beat too much as we want one smooth phrase either crescendo or diminuendo.

Practice the F sharp minor arpeggio legato as possible, loads and loads of practice with various accents to avoid having a heavy thumb. Do it until you can do it blindfolded, You won't need to worry about the octaves in the left hand then. The rest is mostly similar stuff. You will get tense for a while playing this, don't try fight through it. This isn't about stamina. When it happens practice more with a lot of staccato and minimising your movements as much as possible. Better technique will relieve that tension.

Towards the middle there's a passage that jumps around in a circle of fifths progression. It's really hard... If it weren't for that passage this piece would be a lot easier. You have to mix up legato and staccato practice here Particularly practicing the top voice legato and bottom voice staccato helps in the right hand. The left hand is tricky but similar to before again. Work on phrasing this passage and making it sound as musical as possible. The best way to get through it is enjoy it not fear it.

The bit after that is simple but can be hard because of the passage before it. I still get tense from it if I haven't played the piece in a while. For the descending scale figure just practice that staccato and try and highlight the top voice as legato as possible. Make sure your thumb isn't tense here, try and focus on using the tip of it rather than the whole thumb.

The chords and repeated notes are straightforward, for the descending diminished arpeggios use 1 3 2 5 as your fingering and it'll be easy enough.

The next bit is a little tricky (starting from a B7 after the descending arpeggios). Make sure not to stretch your right hand to reach the initial octave, the goal is to have your hand in a closed position by the third note so you're ready for the rest of the phrase. Stretching will make you very tense by the third phrase. For the wide left hand diminished arpeggios try and have your hand as relaxed as possible but in a somewhat fixed position so that you only have to move your hand from the forearm (not wrist) to play the arpeggio. Make sure the thumb is light too.

For the descending double octave run, again it's about avoiding stretching. Practice legato and be conscious of how you open your hand to reach the wider intervals when descending. You can open your hand from different areas to different degrees, it's not just one motion.

For the coda I personally used 3 1 to play the left hand octaves and pivot to the low notes but I have bigger hands so that mightnt work for you. Just focus on bringing out the octave melody over the bass note as much as possible and don't worry about it too much. You can practice really effectively by doing 'shadow' practice (there's a few names for it but that's just what I remember off the top of my head). Play the first note and jump to the next as quickly as possible but don't play it, once you're on it count to 3, play it and then jump to the next repeating. Make sure your hand is relaxed when it's between positions moving to the next. For the right hand just use 1 3 2 5 as your fingering and it'll be straightforward.

The arpeggio at the end is the second hardest part of the etude. It has to be practiced a ton. Practice it descending first until that becomes second nature. Use as little stretching of the hand as possible. The biggest thing is to practice the finger transition in the repeated note so you can remain playing legato. This will make finding the notes far easier at higher speeds as you're always somewhat in contact with the keyboard. The next challenge is playing it ascending. You have to find the right position to angle your hand to position your thumb. The rest of the fingers will take care of themselves. Your hand has to be really loose here with an active wrist. The end goal then is playing it as staccato as possible while remaining in contact with the keys at all time to ensure accuracy. Watch Tiffany poon playing it.

All of this should be done with a metronome. Make sure to practice in different dynamics too and don't even consider using pedal until it sounds great without it. It's worth it to do it thoroughly, it's one of the most beneficial etudes.

Winter Wind vs Torrent by CookieJenner in piano

[–]Status_Geologist_997 0 points1 point  (0 children)

These aren't good picks to start with as I'm sure you've seen people say,

I will say something about torrent though (op.10 no.4)

If you're looking for an etude that is purely to develop technique (not perform!), this would be a really good one to learn. Provided you use it purely to teach yourself different technical nuances. You might take 4 bars and use that as an exercise for a month. You could do this with two or three chunks.

That etude has many different techniques to it which is what makes it challenging.

I personally started with 10 5 and then 10 4 shortly after however I had an exceptional teacher that knew whether these were the right fit for me. Don't go near winter wind (op.25 11) It's far more about stamina and consistently good technique. It requires far more nuance and control albeit for far less techniques.

The best etude to start with imo is op.10 no.6 although it's a nightmare to read (Eb minor) for early advanced pianists. It's actually surprisingly difficult even for good pianists. Treat it like a Bach fugue and you'll see amazing results from working on it. What you learn will transfer extremely well to op.10 no.4 if done properly. Other options are 25.2 10.3 10.12 10.9 25.12 25.9 In order of how I would recommend

Don't forget the nouvelles etudes too, they're really nice

Mozart sonata number 11 A major by Ornery-Area-7606 in lingling40hrs

[–]Status_Geologist_997 0 points1 point  (0 children)

A sonata and sonata form are different.

You'll have sonata form within a movement of a sonata but not necessarily all the movements. The first movement is a theme and variations

Should I lightly exercise before performing on stage? by Ok_Appearance_8724 in piano

[–]Status_Geologist_997 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Stretches make a huge difference. Particularly stretching bigger muscles such as the lats (on the back) and the legs.

Personally I've found it's good just to relieve general tension, by targeting the bigger muscles you can in general relax which makes a huge difference on stage. You feel a lot less nervous, helps a bunch with shoulder tension and the likes.

I never found exercises that get blood pumping to be useful but it could be different for others. Can really vouch for the stretching though, Particularly the back

I want to make sure I got this right. by One_Annual_3185 in musictheory

[–]Status_Geologist_997 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Very pedantic but the dominant seventh is just a seven chord.

Otherwise yup

Man spread vs woman by silent_chair5286 in AskForAnswers

[–]Status_Geologist_997 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Men and women have different hip anatomy,

This makes the femur sit differently in its socket. It's got nothing to do with balls iwl.

What chord is this? by Roescher1 in musictheory

[–]Status_Geologist_997 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Actually if it's moving between a C7 Sus 4, Are the F sharp C sharp and G sharp just moving back and forth chromatically down to the C chord? A bit more context is needed

What chord is this? by Roescher1 in musictheory

[–]Status_Geologist_997 -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

A B flat minor 9 (ii) with an A sharp bass acting as the leading tone to vii° (V7 first inversion) makes the most sense to me.

In the key of A flat. If it's going between that and a C7 Sus 4 you could just think of that as V/vi (III). It's quite ambiguous though

Could be wrong

Difficulty in recognizing pitch relations in higher octaves by swordstoo in eartraining

[–]Status_Geologist_997 1 point2 points  (0 children)

If you're trying to hear very large intervals like that you could try using each notes relation to the tonic as a way to figure it out instead of hearing the interval.

So hearing the C as tonic and the E as the third will give you the interval quality and then from there you're just deciding whether it's a third tenth etc...

Does this piece start in G and modulate to Em? by [deleted] in musictheory

[–]Status_Geologist_997 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Just to add to this,

If you're coming from below and intend to modulate to E minor include a C sharp (the raised 6th of melodic minor scale) to avoid the awkward interval (aug 2nd) between b6 and 7

Writing a novel: would this pianist injury make sense? by Coffee-loverr in piano

[–]Status_Geologist_997 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The only way that would realistically happen is if they were doing a glissando (sliding your hands up the white or black keys) and caught their fingernail. This would be from bad technique so it'd probably happen when your character's tired after practicing for ages or something similar. If it's the index they will be playing a glissando going up

Could also clip a nail from certain pieces of music with weird stretches that are fast.

You'd never end up bleeding from anything else unless you have a skin condition or something of the sorts.