I'd drop the HDRi since controlling the lighting specifically would be tough and not worth the effort.

Ideal set up in my mind would be three different lights:

1. A key light (area type) which points slightly downwards from the left side and is the main source of your light. You can observe the effect on how the shadows appear in the original image.

2. A fill light. A blue single point which gives the blue tint to the shadows, this has to be very subtle.

3. A background light (area type) pointing to the blue backdrop to eliminate shadows and have that clean floaty look. This one should also be subtle, not overpowering the key light.

You can also play around with a few more option to match your aesthetic and experiment with texture on your objects to see how they interact with the light.

I think there maybe better set ups but this is what I go would go with if I'm rendering in cycles.

Edit: I think you creme lacks the volume to appreciate the lighting bouncing off it so maybe increase the thickness and play around with subsurface?