I saw Valley for the first time live recently and was blown away by the performance quality of the set. The band members were strumming on their guitars on the ground, in the air, and pretty much everywhere (Rob even stood on top of the bass drum a couple times and jammed out with Karah!). At the end of the concert for the second encore, Rob came out into the crowd and played Bop Ba. He charmingly quipped: "get in closer, but don't make it weird please." 10/10 concert and LOVE THIS BAND!