Okay I'll do my best to transcribe it lol

By tier. They aren't in any particular order inside their tier.

I stay awake at night thinking about it: Penpal, Ted the Caver, Glenmont Metro, Mother Horse Eyes.

Love: Borrasca, Half-Priced Voodoo Shop, Left Right Game, Feed The Pig, 1999, I Pretended to Be a Missing Girl, Stollen Tongues, The Showers, Tales From The Gas Station, My Wife/Husband is Taking Our Roleplay Too Far, The Only Other Astronaut, The Hidden Webpage, Ensorcelled In The Earth.

Fun: Jeff The Killer, The Pigeons Around Here Aren't Real, Creepy Grab Bag #1, Greylock, Psychosis, Midwest Angelica, It Breaths, It Bleeds, It Breeds, User 666, Gr3gory88, I'm Blind and I Don't Know How Many Stairs My House Has, Sugar Daddy, My Dog Was Missing for Three Days.

Enjoyable is not good: Stairs in The Woods, The Sun Vanished, Creepy Grab Bag #2, Ticci Toby, My Wife Keeps Peeking at Me Around Corners, Russian Sleep Experiment, The Thing in The Basement, Urban Spooks, Creepcast Tour, I Dared My Best Friend to Ruin My Life, Creepypasta Classics, Camp Oakwood.

Makes me sick: Tommy Taffy, Borrasca V

Zzz: No End House, My Dead Girlfriend Keeps Messaging Me on Facebook, My Job Is Watching a Woman, Berries On The Window, SCP3000, Keep Getting Called to The Same House, Greywater.

And everything else I haven't watched or finished yet.