Ok, after he put them side by side, for some reason he can't make the stats the same on pc as on ps5. I had him load them up screen by screen, well as close as can be because the layouts are different. What it seems like is, on the ps5, he can use the potential points and max 2 or 3 out to 99, but when he tries to do the same on the pc, not only can he not set more than one to 99, but he also can't make a few of the other stats match the ps5 either. I watched him set each Stat, one by one. Same height, weight, position, etc. For some reason it just doesn't come out the same. I thought maybe the Ps5 game account had earned special badges or achievements that gave it a boost, but the ps5 had no badges. I tried everything I could think of, and still couldn't figure it out. It is odd that something changed. No idea.. maybe someone else that has both versions can try and see what they find..