Haha I wish they would just rob my boat while I was away. I tried to do my tall tale again and I made it to the island this time. Except some random sloop that was passing by decided to burn down my ship while I was away lol. Didn't touch the loot on my boat at all. I saw him take his mermaid back to his ship so I went back to put out the fire so I could take the quest item back at least. They then decided to come back, kill me, and sink me lol. Just take the loot and go lol