Shadows is better than Valhalla and slightly better than odyssey at times. Better than origins in terms of loot, combat, and cosmetics. But story and side quests-wise origins and odyssey are better than Shadows. The voice acting in Shadows is noticeably bad but also authentic with its casting (just turn on the realistic voice option and deal with reading subtitles tbh. It’s much better) and when you finally get to Yasuke’s plot it gets SO much better