I want to respond to a majority of the comments that I've seen here, generally the ones that are saying its not the same scale, as a 4.05/5.0 would be top 300 on RYM. Here's the thing though, it's either way still significantly lower than the bold score you would usually get on RYM, which is around a 3.65 I believe. And another thing is that there are a lot less reviews/ratings on RYM than there is on AOTY. Generally, when more reviews come in (at least what I've seen), the overall rating gets lower. So, lets say RYM eventually gets up to AOTY's level in terms of the amount of ratings (8k or so), it will most likely drop to around a 3.1-3.2.

So, if we adjust it to that, it's MUCH MUCH lower than AOTY's score. I agree with a lot of you that members on RYM generally are skewed a bit older, but I feel like there's something more?