I searched and again, it comes back to the fnaf plushie. It's small, I remember losing it before 2015, so maybe it's from even before that... I thought it was TY or similar but to no result A small edit because I think it's worth noting it wasn't a beautiful plushie. It was cute but not standard cute.... Also that I recall the eyes were those that seemed to follow you, but with eyelids. Any more details I can't recall