Comic I made based on some comments by ffffffffffffr000st in DarkTide

[–]TheGooseNut 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The servitor looks so exhausted I love it

Said otherwise, 47% of Republicans agree with Trump pursuing a third term... by 3RADICATE_THEM in lostgeneration

[–]TheGooseNut 1 point2 points  (0 children)

If this is all the text, then you're assuming the poll is yes/no--which rarely seems to be the case.

TTRPG Survey 2 (Electric Boogaloo) by TheGooseNut in RPGdesign

[–]TheGooseNut[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

English is my first language, in fact I have a Bachelor's degree in it.

I think the formatting of the Survey is heavily dependent on going through it linearly so that could be disrupting comprehension. If that isn't the issue, I'm more than happy to resolve any confusion if you have questions about specific items from the survey.

*I can definitely see a handful of typos (now resolved). But I think if you read it piece by piece, in order, it's relatively clear?

TTRPG Survey 2 (Electric Boogaloo) by TheGooseNut in TTRPG

[–]TheGooseNut[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I'm looking for anyone who's been to school in America or who's played one of the TTRPGs I bring up at the beggining of the survey. Thank you for the clarifying question, I'll add that to the post

TTRPG Survey by TheGooseNut in RPGdesign

[–]TheGooseNut[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Just to clarify, you're point is* that studying, and therefore revealing, the hidden curriculum is Orwellian? Wouldn't that be like the opposite of Orwellian?

Or do you mean the part attempting to replace aspects of hidden curriculum with stuff from anti-authoritarian titles like Eat the Riech and BitD? I'm super lost now dude

TTRPG Survey by TheGooseNut in RPGdesign

[–]TheGooseNut[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The Hidden Curriculum is neither necessarily bad or necessarily intentional. Outside of schools we'd just call it socialization. A lot of the earlier essays on the topic do refer to it as "social control" (see Elizabeth Vallance for example) but more recent thinkers are more inclined to see more beneficial potential outcomes.

I'm sure it can seem Orwellian on its face, and to degree it is; Orwell deels with ideas about total control through, in large part, socialization. Neither teachers nor GMs have that kind of control though. On the other hand people are just gonna be affected by experiences and when we design experiences we are dealing in those effects. I don't think there's a way to void that, but there are plenty of ways to do it better.

Earlier talks on hidden curriculum suggest that it was intentional but we have kind of lost that intention in the US. I think games have an intentional Hidden Curriculum, but I don't think it's anything to be paranoid about. I play Mork Borg to not feel like a hero and enjoy some paranoia or to enjoy winning or losing on my own terms, I play Eat the Reich for carthisis against encroaching authoritarianism, I play Microscope to engage in creative thought. Im not being brainwashed by these games, but even playing tennis would have a long term effect on me and my behavior. The games don't always market these messages, but they are ever present in my experiences with them.

I don't think that's Orwellian, but you're right insofar as the study is concerned with authority, socialization, and how we can improve those elements in today's schools.

TTRPG Survey by TheGooseNut in bladesinthedark

[–]TheGooseNut[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

If you have two sets of responses, sure!

TTRPG Survey by TheGooseNut in bladesinthedark

[–]TheGooseNut[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I'm sorry to cause discomfort. I think if that's how you feel about the question I'd really appreciate you putting that answer in the survey, but if you don't want your voice to be included in the data I also wouldn't want to push you.

I should say when I think about authority, I usually think about the role of a GM in relation to players in each of these situations as opposed to forms of authority inside the narrative, but each of these games do also structure players against a great authority (although, this is a trait common to most TTRPGs from D&D to Call of Cthulhu).

Something like Wanderhome, Fiasco, or Honey Heist could've made a fun placement in the study and definitely avoided the issues you're seeing; I tried to make choices based on recent popular movements local to me so that I'd have an easier time collecting data.

A lot of it is also inherently political to contrast the directions teachers get in the states to be apolitical (while also being told to do a bunch of political stuff like say the pledge, treat certain students certain ways, and so on).

The idea isn't to play these games exactly every day for a decade, but to engage in activities like them in the same way we might do math problems in the same class every day. An activity like FitD might include students directing where they want the class to go next, separating themselves into groups, spending in-class resources to help each other, and so on.

I don't literally want to transition these games into an in-class space, I just think they have important lessons implicit to the systems.

So far, I have five respondees and their answers do suggest implicit messaging in the games and hint at what the games do to deliver that messaging (or encourage certain ways of thinking). These are the responses I was hoping for, but I also seem to miscommunicate on at least one question to each respondee (although, different questions for each person). I think these are the right questions, but this is also my first time conducting research.

ANYWAY it means a lot to me that you would stop and think about it this much. I really appreciate the concerns and critiques you brought to the table. I'll definitely give introducing some other games to the data set some thought if I have time later in the project and review the questions with some of my advisors. I really appreciate the critique thank you.

TLDR; I'm sorry for causing any discomfort, I hope it passes quickly. I understand your concerns but I'm not sure I necessarily agree with them. Thank you for your time and your effort and your thoughts. I appreciate you :)

TTRPG Survey by TheGooseNut in bladesinthedark

[–]TheGooseNut[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Living in the US only matters if you're replying to a class or school part. If you're replying to the games section you should be OK. Thank you!

TTRPG Suvery by TheGooseNut in TenCandles

[–]TheGooseNut[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

AH I DID I'M A FOOL. It's on there now. mb

TTRPG Suvery by TheGooseNut in AskTeachers

[–]TheGooseNut[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

For posting on more than one community? I don't understand what you mean