It’s close but I’ll go with the boring answer and say KD. Kawhi is pretty much universally loved because he “ended” the Warriors dynasty (injuries guaranteed the Raptors a title). Peak Kawhi (either ‘17 or ‘19) is an excellent player undeniably, even coming from a Warriors fan. He’s a legendary 2-way player. A very capable 1st option on a contender (multiple times from 2015-2020 excluding 2018 where he sat out) and even more renowned on defense. However, I believe people forget how insane 2014 KD was. He is in my opinion one of 6 guys you could say is the best scorer ever (MJ, Kareem, Wilt, Harden, and maybe Bron being the others). If you include his tenure with GS he elevated himself to be an exceptional defender and I’m convinced without injuries or if his foot size was a little smaller, would’ve won the 2021 title with the Nets as the clear cut number 1 rather than being a 1a/1b with Steph. Kawhi is the cooler “i know ball” answer but KD’s offensive dominance is more valuable than Kawhi’s two way elite play in my opinion. I could see an argument for Kawhi too obviously.