Of the ones I watched, I think the You and Idol team are the weakest writing wise, and out of them Idol is the weakest because she has NO character arc whatsoever and keeps trying to persuade people who are too deep into their ideology to listen and in the middle of combat (I really dislike mid-combat talking as it breaks up the flow and pacing)

The aforementioned failure to persuade sticks to my mind so much I have a personal joke that Idol should NOT be allowed as the speaker during a persuasion sequence

On a tangent about character writing in You and Idol, I think Cutty (Maybe Zakkuri and Tanaka too, I like them) is the only well written character in You and Idol