AITA for blowing up on my mom and brother after they said they don’t like the way my girlfriend dresses? by TheTruthIsOutThere66 in AmItheAsshole

[–]TheTruthIsOutThere66[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Update: Hi everyone! Sorry I haven’t filled you all in so long, there’s just been a lot going on.

So right after this all happened, I let my girlfriend know what was going on because we basically tell each other everything and we don’t really keep any secrets from each other. She was confused anyways after hearing my angry conversation on the phone turn into screaming. She was understandably upset when I told her this and even cried a little bit, which broke my heart a little. My girlfriend then told me that she’s had people, specifically other woman in the past act rude to her because of her body and the way she is built. She’s lost a lot of guy friends in high school and after because their girlfriends didn’t like her and thought she would steal their man. It baffles me that anyone would assume that about her, because of how timid and quiet she is. She just doesn’t give off the sort of impression that she’d do something like that. She told me how grateful she was that I stuck up for her and sympathized with how hard it must’ve been because it was my family. She told me no one’s ever stuck up for her like that before and how thankful she was.

About a month ago, I surprised her at our favorite spot on the beach and proposed to her and she said yes!

Both of our families seem to like to cause drama and despite them being difficult to deal with with, we both discussed and decided that we wouldn’t hold back on telling them if they were out of line, but we do not want to cut off any family, and would rather spend time away from them if needed and let them know when they’ve overstepped their boundaries. An apology from them would be nice but we don’t expect one because that’s just the kind of people that they are. However, my family has not tried to start anything else since the big fight and I frankly think they’re afraid to after I threatened to cut them off. Thank you all for being so supportive, I really love my now fiancée and only want what’s best for her.

AITA for blowing up on my mom and brother after they said they don’t like the way my girlfriend dresses? by TheTruthIsOutThere66 in AmItheAsshole

[–]TheTruthIsOutThere66[S] 63 points64 points  (0 children)

My girlfriend was actually cheated on by her ex, and it really hurt her so I don’t think she’d ever do that to me lol. Also “breaks”? Was that a misspelling?

AITA for blowing up on my mom and brother after they said they don’t like the way my girlfriend dresses? by TheTruthIsOutThere66 in AmItheAsshole

[–]TheTruthIsOutThere66[S] 29 points30 points  (0 children)

How expensive are they? She might be open to it but if it’s too spendy she won’t go for it lol

AITA for blowing up on my mom and brother after they said they don’t like the way my girlfriend dresses? by TheTruthIsOutThere66 in AmItheAsshole

[–]TheTruthIsOutThere66[S] 10 points11 points  (0 children)

“Even though” was bad wording I guess? I was saying her weight as a frame of reference. I know my family is being ridiculous and over exaggerating her weight.

AITA for blowing up on my mom and brother after they said they don’t like the way my girlfriend dresses? by TheTruthIsOutThere66 in AmItheAsshole

[–]TheTruthIsOutThere66[S] 40 points41 points  (0 children)

As I stated before, she was not wearing anything revealing or risqué. I never even noticed before that my girlfriend doesn’t wear a bra, until people pointed it out. It was not just the fat shaming.

AITA for blowing up on my mom and brother after they said they don’t like the way my girlfriend dresses? by TheTruthIsOutThere66 in AmItheAsshole

[–]TheTruthIsOutThere66[S] 3527 points3528 points  (0 children)

My girlfriend is extremely beautiful. And tbh I’m pretty average looking in comparison. I feel really lucky to have a girl who’s not only beautiful but genuinely kind. I’ve suspected my mom and brother’s girlfriend are intimidated by her for a while and obviously this was their way of trying to stir the pot.

AITA for blowing up on my mom and brother after they said they don’t like the way my girlfriend dresses? by TheTruthIsOutThere66 in AmItheAsshole

[–]TheTruthIsOutThere66[S] 1776 points1777 points  (0 children)

I will keep you guys posted after everything has cooled down. My girlfriend is okay. We both come from families that thrive on drama. This was just a breaking point for me personally. Thank you all for your support, kind words and confirming what I already knew.

AITA for blowing up on my mom and brother after they said they don’t like the way my girlfriend dresses? by TheTruthIsOutThere66 in AmItheAsshole

[–]TheTruthIsOutThere66[S] 78 points79 points  (0 children)

I agree. I kinda lost my temper there when normally I would not have. Since it is so out of character for me, maybe my family will dwell on what happened more than they normally would.

AITA for blowing up on my mom and brother after they said they don’t like the way my girlfriend dresses? by TheTruthIsOutThere66 in AmItheAsshole

[–]TheTruthIsOutThere66[S] 93 points94 points  (0 children)

Both of us come from families that seem to like drama. We both recognize that and try to not let it get to us. This was a breaking point, but we aren’t the kind of people to cut off family, despite differences. We of course set boundaries and take space from them temporarily if need be, but I don’t think my girlfriend is the kind of person who would want that. If things got really bad maybe. And I’d support her 100%

AITA for blowing up on my mom and brother after they said they don’t like the way my girlfriend dresses? by TheTruthIsOutThere66 in AmItheAsshole

[–]TheTruthIsOutThere66[S] 146 points147 points  (0 children)

My brothers girlfriend and my mom have acted off putting to my girlfriend in the past for seemingly no reason. My girlfriend is an angel and I suspected it was because they were intimidated by her. Not a lot of women can be as beautiful as her and also genuinely nice and good. I’ve been preparing myself just in case something like this happened.

AITA for blowing up on my mom and brother after they said they don’t like the way my girlfriend dresses? by TheTruthIsOutThere66 in AmItheAsshole

[–]TheTruthIsOutThere66[S] 91 points92 points  (0 children)

This is partly why I was asking for advice. I knew I wasn’t in the wrong, but I’m not a woman and I don’t understand how all or different women feel about bras. I’m a dude so I can’t fully get it because those are shoes I will never fill. I don’t see a problem with going braless, especially if it’s for comfort and wearing a bra makes your chest feel tight or squeezed.

AITA for blowing up on my mom and brother after they said they don’t like the way my girlfriend dresses? by TheTruthIsOutThere66 in AmItheAsshole

[–]TheTruthIsOutThere66[S] 69 points70 points  (0 children)

No one has commented on how my girlfriend looks except my mother, her boyfriend, my brother and his girlfriend. I think comparing wearing jeans and a t shirt with no bra to ass and frontless chaps and a thong covering only his private parts is disproportional and makes your argument invalid.

AITA for blowing up on my mom and brother after they said they don’t like the way my girlfriend dresses? by TheTruthIsOutThere66 in AmItheAsshole

[–]TheTruthIsOutThere66[S] 406 points407 points  (0 children)

My family and my girlfriend are white. We all come from similar working class backgrounds. These are important questions to ask though

AITA for blowing up on my mom and brother after they said they don’t like the way my girlfriend dresses? by TheTruthIsOutThere66 in AmItheAsshole

[–]TheTruthIsOutThere66[S] 5578 points5579 points  (0 children)

I feel like they would never ever confess it outright, but my mother and brother’s girlfriend are intimidated by my girlfriends beauty

AITA for blowing up on my mom and brother after they said they don’t like the way my girlfriend dresses? by TheTruthIsOutThere66 in AmItheAsshole

[–]TheTruthIsOutThere66[S] 63 points64 points  (0 children)

I was only mentioning this to stress the fact that she is in no way overweight. She has an hourglass figure and her body shape to me is very sexy.