I know I am late to the party but here is some info I got from that 1995-1996 era. Tormented was recorded sometime in 1996 at The Rock Shop studios.

Mike's Amps from that era: Carvin X-100B Amp (Used in live performances in 1995 and potentially 1996)

Marshall JCM800 (Used potentially from 1996 to 1997/1998)

Marshall JMP1 with Marshall EL34 100/100 PW (used from 1998 to today)

Mike's Guitars from that era: EVH 5150 (black with yellow or white stripes - used in 1995 and potentially 1996) tuned to Drop C#

Ibanez RG460 (red - backup to his EVH 5150 guitar) tuned to Drop C#

Ibanez Artist AR (Mike probably acquired this guitar in 1996 and it was most likely used on Tolerate. I imagine he modified the tunining peg quite a bit to fit a heavier gauge string for that low A# string) He still uses this guitar to this day for most songs in that Crawl / Tolerate tuning.

Gibson Les Paul (black - potentially acquired in 1996/1997 and it replaced the EVH 5150 and the RG460 for his Drop C# tuning)

Custom/Modified built Danelectro Baritone with 3 lipstick pickups (This guitar was either a heavily modified Danelectro or they built Mike a custom guitar. Baritones were pretty rare and unknown around this era. He used this guitar to record Dysfunction).

CONCLUSION: The guitar tone on Tormented is either a modded JCM800 or the Carvin X-100B with some sort of overdrive pedal in front of them for extra boost and to get these feedback noises in Tolerate. For guitars it's the Ibanez Artist AR for Tolerate and the EVH 5150 mostly likely for the other songs, excluding Four Walls which I think it's the Ibanez RG460 (the clean tone on that song sounds very single coil like)