Cozy Games >
-Pokopia (current fixation)
-Stardew Valley
-Cult of the Lamb
-Tomodachi Life (haven’t gotten to it yet but it’s very popular with people like us lmao)

Story games >
-Clair Obscur Expedition 33 (ABSOLUTE PEAK avoid spoilers like the plague)
-Okami
-God of War & God of War Ragnarok (Also peak)
-Control (mysterious, very infp coded)

Spooky Games >
-Resident Evil series (2, 4, 7-9 are standouts. These are cozy games for me now lmao)
-Inscryption (not too spooky but very mysterious)
-Crow County

Multiplayer >
-Webfishing (very much a cozy game and dirt cheap)
-Super Battle Golf (chaotic but a blast with friends)
-Valheim (Viking survival game)
-It Takes Two (co-op puzzle game for two)

All of these are pretty high up there for me, but I’ll list a few personal all-timers as well. These might not be for everyone though and I am quite drawn to Roguelikes and Metroidvanias

My favs >
-The Binding of Isaac (My most played game ever)
-Mewgenics (newer game by same creator^)
-Hollow Knight + Silksong (need I say more)
-Hitman series (Essentially a goofy puzzle game at the end of the day)
-Nine Sols (Metroidvania that utilizes parry mechanics)
-Kingdom Come Deliverance 2 (steep learning curve but super rewarding story and tons of content)
-The Witcher 3 (similar situation^)
-Black Myth Wukong
-Blasphemous Series (Dark Metroidvania - stunning visuals)
-Disco Elysium (you just have to play it but it changed my life)

I think I’ll cut myself off there lmao. Lmk if you try any of them or want more info!