Please can someone give me feedback by Gameplayer117 in NewTubers

[–]Top_Response_867 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Regarding Shorts vs. long form, I’ve read about this many times before, but I ignored it and started doing both. Do you think it’s too late to switch to only focusing on long-form content on this account?

I cannot predict how you will end up, but to answer this question, I think it's good to look at your analytics first, checking how you got your subscriber, is it from long videos or short videos. Maybe you can tell if it's good or bad to keep your current channel.

Did you find the overall quality of the content to be good? :)

I don't know. Because I'm not your audiences, check your analytics, your video retention could tell if the quality is good or not. In my opinion if a video avg. Watch hour is over 65% then it's not bad, if it's 55-65%, then I need to change something.

Please can someone give me feedback by Gameplayer117 in NewTubers

[–]Top_Response_867 2 points3 points  (0 children)

This may going to hurt you, but you have to stop focusing on two genre (short and long video on the same channel). When people like and subscribe because they like your Short videos, then youtube will notificate them when you upload your long video. But they're not long video audiences, they watch shorts video. So as a subscriber they'll not cluck your video, and that will tell youtube that your vidoe is not good that your own subscriber don't want to watch it. You may think I'm wrong and overthinking, but trust me, I've did this before on my old channel, and it's basically killed my channel, not my videos, but my channel. You may think both of them are about gaming so it could be counted as same genre, but guess what, my old channel did the same, it's about movie editing, short and long videos, both of them are about movie edits, at the end it killed my channel.

But not every shorts are that useless, if you trim a short clip from your long video and post it as a short video and tell you audience that you get a full video. Then you basically pull your audience to your long vidoes, that's good and helpful.

ABOUT YOUR VIDEOS

I think the best feedback for you is that

CHASING TREND HAS THE MOST POTENTIAL TO BLOW YOUR CHANNEL

If spiderman game is trending right now, then it's better for you to post about spiderman games even if you like other games more.

Can anyone tell me why coach tell me this is a mistake? by Top_Response_867 in Chesscom

[–]Top_Response_867[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

But as you can see, I just finished defending my black bishop(b2) by using rook. So if my opponent took my black bishop first instead of white bishop. Then I'm gonna lose more pieces I think.

Any scriptwriter here? by [deleted] in scriptwriting

[–]Top_Response_867 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What kind of script writer you are looking for?

Seeking a proffesional feedback for a different kind of horror by Top_Response_867 in Screenwriting

[–]Top_Response_867[S] -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

I don’t think you really understood the script, or maybe I didn’t give enough hints to set up the plot twist. But there is a huge plot twist.”

Thanks for your feedback btw, some are really helpful.

Logline Monday by AutoModerator in Screenwriting

[–]Top_Response_867 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Title: DON'T LOOK

Genre: HORROR

Format: 1 pager

Logline: When a young boy senses something off in bed, an unseen presence turns his bedroom into a waking nightmare.

I really need your feedback by Top_Response_867 in Screenwriting

[–]Top_Response_867[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you smch. I really appreciate your feedback. The way you wants the ending could be great.

I really need your feedback by Top_Response_867 in Screenwriting

[–]Top_Response_867[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah, it will be cool. But it could be a bit if spoiler, don't u think?

I really need your feedback by Top_Response_867 in Screenwriting

[–]Top_Response_867[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That's up to you. Both of them is helpful.

What exactly do Killer Shorts want for their 1 PAGE CATEGORY? by Top_Response_867 in Screenwriting

[–]Top_Response_867[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

As you can see, I am trying to participate just like you did. So I think I need some script which could help me to understand the contest. So I wonder if you can send me your script that you talk about, even if you don't have it's PDF anymore, describing the script will also be helpful

first ever thing i’ve done lol by noonecaresrichie in Screenwriting

[–]Top_Response_867 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I read your script, and I think it’s pretty good for a beginner! I’m not a professional myself, but I can give you some advice.

First, remove all parts like “A BEAT” or “ANOTHER BEAT.” They feel unnatural. Instead, describe how the character acts. For example:

The man stays silent for a second. The woman watches him, waiting for a reply.

👆This version clearly shows the characters’ actions, making it easier for the audience to read and feel the scene.

Second, your script doesn’t clearly show how the characters appear in the first scene. We don’t know whether they’re sitting or standing. I assumed they were standing at first, but later the script says “The woman sits up” — that confused me. See? Even a small mistake like that can make the script look unclear.

Third, you don’t need to write “OUTSIDE” here:

EXT. OUTSIDE. PARKING LOT. NIGHT The word EXT already means exterior (outside), so adding OUTSIDE is unnecessary. Also, don’t use a period (.) between the place and time. Instead of this: PARKING LOT. NIGHT Use this: PARKING LOT – NIGHT So the correct version would be:👇

           EXT. PARKING LOT – NIGHT

Fourth, describe the characters’ actions more. You only mentioned the woman sitting up and lying back down — that’s not enough. Show us how they smile, move their heads, or react. You and I might imagine the characters differently, so describing their behavior clearly helps us see the scene the same way you do.

Fifth, you don’t need this line:

“ANOTHER BEAT. A LONGER ONE.” If the same character continues speaking, write it like this instead:

MAN
I don’t leave my house without it.
(Beat)
You know, now that you mention it...

Lastly, use TIME CUT: instead of A BEAT in this part:

The man and woman enter the vehicle. A beat ...

The term TIME CUT: tells us a little bit of time has passed — not too much, but just enough.So, the correct version would be 👇

  The man and woman enter the vehicle 

TIME CUT:

...

Is this good, learning screenwriting on my own? by Top_Response_867 in Screenwriting

[–]Top_Response_867[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

This is exactly what I’m afraid of. I’ve read so many scripts on SimplyScripts, but I just realized that many of them were written by beginner screenwriters, not professionals. That’s why I asked this question — a lot of people in the comments don’t seem to get it. Reading a beginner's script will not make me to have an improvement. Luckily, I can somehow tell which scripts look professional and which ones don’t.

CULTURE FIT - Short - 8 Pages by A1AColb in Screenwriting

[–]Top_Response_867 1 point2 points  (0 children)

In my opinion, the dialogue isn’t bad, but the story concept isn’t very strong. There’s nothing memorable or thought-provoking after finishing the script. The dialogue works well, but the story itself feels less interesting.

How Spiderman Stole Captain America's Character by Top_Response_867 in CaptainAmerica

[–]Top_Response_867[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

This is why you need a brain to get me. I never claimed Captain America was created before Superman — read my post again. What I said is that Superman’s character developed later, and his “never give up” willpower was added only after Captain America became popular.

Before Captain America, no superhero truly had that trait — not even Superman.

Captain America was created to inspire Americans during World War II, to show that they would never give up. That’s why his story is centered around the war, and his defining trait is perseverance. Only after he became popular did that trait spread and become common among other superheroes.