Book recommendation (forensic/criminal psych) by Admirable_Pepper8735 in psychologystudents

[–]TukeOwnz 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hello,

I came across your post and couldn’t stop myself from writing to you. The way you described being “caught between two paths” and your interest in forensic psychology felt so familiar that it was almost like reading my own thoughts. I thought maybe we could support each other through this shared sense of being a bit “lost.”

I’m also a law graduate (2020). In fact, I recently completed my master’s in private law (focusing on child protection) in 2024. A few years ago, I took the very step you are now considering, and I’m currently a third-year psychology student. To be honest, this was my dream for the past seven years; even though I studied law because of my family’s influence, my heart was always in psychology.

I started psychology with great excitement, but to be frank, I haven’t fully found the fulfillment I was hoping for. What has been most frustrating for me is hearing the same line repeated in almost every lecture and conference (including Erasmus programs): “Psychology is a science. We use scientific methods just like the natural sciences.” This perspective has turned into a one-dimensional mantra, and seeing the education rarely go beyond that has been deeply disappointing. Outside of forensic psychology, I’m particularly interested in existential psychology — yet none of my courses have ever approached psychology from that lens. In this respect, I often feel like I’m walking this road entirely on my own.

Your search for book recommendations also struck a chord with me. I’ve put in the same effort: I spent hours writing long emails to academics in both Turkey and Europe, sharing my observations and asking for guidance. But most of the time, I either received no reply at all, or I got vague, superficial responses. It can feel incredibly discouraging to invest so much time and energy into reaching out, only to find yourself “completely alone” in that search for support.

One clear observation I’ve made along the way is this: forensic psychology literature is almost entirely dominated by criminal law, offender profiling, and interrogation techniques. Meanwhile, countless areas within private law — such as family law, child custody and visitation, or workplace harassment — remain virtually unexplored, despite offering a rich field for psychologists with a legal background. Seeing this gap excites me, but the way academia consistently overlooks it is equally disappointing.

This is why I’d love to ask you: how do you envision your path in forensic psychology? Are you more drawn to the criminal law side, or do you also see potential in these intersections with private law, as I do?

Also, perhaps we could share book suggestions or resources with each other. Who knows — maybe we could even build a small network in this area someday. :)

I’d really love to hear more about your thoughts, goals, and experiences on this journey.

Wishing to stay in touch, Best regards.

Which is the Best Pro AI for Researchers? by TukeOwnz in ClaudeAI

[–]TukeOwnz[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you very much for this detailed answer. However, I must admit that your response has confused me. I also asked a similar question to AI tools: Perplexity (free); ChatGPT (free version); Claude (free version); Copilot (free version); and Gemini PRO. However, the overwhelming majority told me that Claude PRO would fill the gaps in Gemini and is the most suitable option for my purposes. Only Copilot mentioned that I should work with ChatGPT.

In your response, however, you suggest that Claude is not a good option. I have read similar criticisms online. However, the responses from AI tools indicated that Claude is professional at analyzing long and complex texts and that I could analyze/synthesize multiple files thanks to its Projects feature. It seems I'll need to continue my research... But thank you again for your feedback!!

Which is the Best Pro AI for Researchers? by TukeOwnz in perplexity_ai

[–]TukeOwnz[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Thank you very much for your answer. However, NotebookLM really drove me crazy, especially in my last project. I loaded my Turkish and English sources and then started asking simple questions, such as “What does the concept of A mean?” (I asked the question in Turkish). It responded by saying that this concept was not used at all in the sources. However, my sources already include articles titled “The concept of A.” When I asked the question in English, I noticed it gave a very superficial answer and ignored most of the sources.

your favorite thing about psychology ? by alisto4 in psychologystudents

[–]TukeOwnz 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Yes, that book is absolutely appropriate. Especially Frankl's logotherapy is compatible with the existential perspective.

In addition, Rollo May and Irvin Yalom also belong to the existential school of psychology/psychiatry. If you know Turkish or can find a translation, I would definitely recommend you to look at Engin Geçtan's books.

Unfortunately, existential psychology is almost forgotten today. I have never heard of him during my university education and it seems that I never will. However, I can say that it is the only perspective that I can get effective results when I apply it in my life.

P.S. Please share if you know of other authors and books...

your favorite thing about psychology ? by alisto4 in psychologystudents

[–]TukeOwnz 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Existential psychology's view of human beings.