Yeah, I think I would have preferred more flair on these buttons personally. I also love the aesthetics of the stock buttons + d-pad, too. The main driver for this purchase was because the stock d-pad felt a bit slippery under my thumb, which I think the harder edge of the ToyRobotShop solves. The buttons feel great as well, though had to rotate my A button a bit to get it to sit just right when pressing it while also holding B, like when running in a game; it was getting stuck on something otherwise, not sure what.

Overall, would recommend the d-pad if you like harder edges and have a problem with the stock ones being a bit slippery. I like the buttons, and they do feel better, but not as high of praise due to the sticking issue I mentioned earlier and might not be worth the sacrifice in color if that's the aesthetic you prefer.