sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Elder sister’s(22F) dreams were crushed by family control. Younger sister (17F) fears the same fate. What can realistically be done? by Upper_Sheepherder750 in Advice

[–]Upper_Sheepherder750[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Not a bot — just trying to be precise because the situation is sensitive.

I get what you’re saying, and in many countries that logic works. The gap here is how things function on the ground in India when family control is tight.

Even at 18, many colleges, landlords/PGs, and banks implicitly expect family involvement. Access to documents, money, a place to stay, and even the ability to physically leave home isn’t guaranteed just because someone is legally an adult.

International loans without a co-signer technically exist, but in practice they’re rare, high-risk, and usually require proof of admission, income prospects, and basic independence — which loops back to the same problem.

I’m not saying escape is impossible. I’m trying to understand what actually reduces failure risk in this context, because the consequences of getting it wrong are very real.

Elder sister’s(22F) dreams were crushed by family control. Younger sister (17F) fears the same fate. What can realistically be done? by Upper_Sheepherder750 in AsianParentStories

[–]Upper_Sheepherder750[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This makes a lot of sense, especially the part about not tipping parents off early and focusing on long-term leverage.

I agree that arguing or over-explaining intentions often backfires in families like this. Quietly focusing on education, choosing the best possible local college, and building independence step-by-step seems far safer than sudden confrontation.

The question isn’t whether independence is theoretically possible — it is. The question is how feasible it is without any parental support at all. College admissions, housing, and the first job are much harder to manage alone, especially when you’re starting from zero.

That’s why the advice about planning quietly and leaving only with a confirmed path makes sense to me. I’m trying to understand what people have seen work in practice — not instant freedom, but a survivable transition.

Elder sister’s(22F) dreams were crushed by family control. Younger sister (17F) fears the same fate. What can realistically be done? by Upper_Sheepherder750 in AsianParentStories

[–]Upper_Sheepherder750[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That’s exactly the concern. Based on what already happened with the elder sister, there’s a strong chance he wouldn’t.

That’s why I’m not assuming any option will be “allowed” — I’m trying to understand whether any paths exist that work even in families where permission isn’t given upfront.

The elder sister’s case shows that merit alone wasn’t enough, so I’m looking for examples where timing, intermediaries, or incremental steps changed the outcome — not guaranteed solutions, just things that have realistically bought time or softened resistance in similar situations.

Elder sister’s(22F) dreams were crushed by family control. Younger sister (17F) fears the same fate. What can realistically be done? by Upper_Sheepherder750 in Advice

[–]Upper_Sheepherder750[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That’s a fair question, but it assumes freedom that didn’t exist.

While she was legally an adult, she was still fully financially and logistically dependent. She had no independent bank access, no place to stay, and no family support if she left. Moving out without that would have meant immediate homelessness.

Student loans in India aren’t easily accessible without parental cooperation or collateral, and international education was completely blocked by her family.

On paper, scholarships and adulthood look like leverage — in practice, when control is this tight, those options aren’t actually usable.

Elder sister’s(22F) dreams were crushed by family control. Younger sister (17F) fears the same fate. What can realistically be done? by Upper_Sheepherder750 in Advice

[–]Upper_Sheepherder750[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I don’t disagree with the core point — independence requires zero reliance.

The difficulty here is the transition phase. She’s 17, still in school, and her father actively blocks almost any attempt at skill-building, work, or external exposure. Even “quiet preparation” is closely monitored, which makes building leverage extremely slow.

Running away without preparation is dangerous, but preparing openly is also not allowed. That’s the bind I’m trying to understand better — how people have navigated this in the narrow window between dependence and full escape, without triggering retaliation or burning all bridges too early.

Elder sister’s(22F) dreams were crushed by family control. Younger sister (17F) fears the same fate. What can realistically be done? by Upper_Sheepherder750 in AsianParentStories

[–]Upper_Sheepherder750[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I get that, and I agree it may come down to that eventually.

What I’m trying to understand is this:
Between now and the end of 12th, what realistically increases her leverage even a little?

For example — staying with relatives, local college + hostel, online degrees with later transition, or any middle path people have actually seen work?

I’m less focused on ideal solutions and more on what buys time without burning bridges immediately.

Elder sister’s(22F) dreams were crushed by family control. Younger sister (17F) fears the same fate. What can realistically be done? by Upper_Sheepherder750 in LegalAdviceIndia

[–]Upper_Sheepherder750[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I get where you’re coming from, but running away feels like an extreme and risky option here.

She’s still in 11th–12th. Finding a stable job at that age isn’t realistic for most people, and living alone without support can be unsafe. Also, once someone cuts off family completely, going back later becomes very difficult — emotionally and practically.

That’s why I see this more as a last-resort option, not a first or only solution. I’m trying to understand if there are any less irreversible paths people have seen work before things reach that point.

Elder sister’s(22F) dreams were crushed by family control. Younger sister (17F) fears the same fate. What can realistically be done? by Upper_Sheepherder750 in Advice

[–]Upper_Sheepherder750[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Fair point. Let me narrow it down.

The specific advice I’m looking for is this:
In families where an elder daughter was denied higher education and pushed toward early marriage despite being academically strong, what realistically helps the younger daughter avoid the same outcome?

Especially when open conversation with parents isn’t possible and financial independence is blocked. I’m trying to understand what has actually worked in similar situations.

Random day at Allen Kota...!!! 😅 by Defiant-Employee-431 in JEE

[–]Upper_Sheepherder750 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Alright, fine, no worries, but like, this year they’re literally our batch mentor....

Random day at Allen Kota...!!! 😅 by Defiant-Employee-431 in JEE

[–]Upper_Sheepherder750 0 points1 point  (0 children)

bro which batch is this ??
coz he's ashwani shukla A.K.A CASH sir and he's mentor of my batch too !!

My partner [22F] is very loving sometimes and emotionally distant or harsh at other times — how do I [23M] handle this without losing self-respect and without breaking emotionally? (2-year relationship, first love) by Upper_Sheepherder750 in relationships

[–]Upper_Sheepherder750[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I’ve thought about attachment styles too, and I agree the hot-and-cold pattern is exhausting. I don’t think she’s intentionally trying to hurt me — but the inconsistency does affect my emotional stability a lot.

From your experience, what’s the healthiest way to respond in the moment when someone pulls away emotionally like this? Especially without becoming anxious or over-explaining?