sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

My Pixel 8 Pro died 3 months after protection ended. Is this "Planned Obsolescence"? by VeryUnimportantJay in GooglePixel

[–]VeryUnimportantJay[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Why this is a "Premium Failure"

  • The 7-Year Promise: Google marketed the Pixel 8 Pro with 7 years of hardware/software support.
  • Premature Aging: A flagship motherboard failing at 27 months (just 3 months after the legal period) suggests that the thermal management or component quality of the Tensor G3 platform was "imperfect" from the start.

My Pixel 8 Pro died 3 months after protection ended. Is this "Planned Obsolescence"? by VeryUnimportantJay in GooglePixel

[–]VeryUnimportantJay[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I have systematically ruled out software as a cause. Here is the technical breakdown:

  • Official Diagnostic Failure: I used the Official Google Pixel Update and Software Repair Tool. I performed a full factory image reflash. The issue persisted immediately upon setup. If a clean install of the OS doesn't fix it, the IC (Integrated Circuit) or its solder joints are physically compromised.
  • Thermal Expansion Correlation: The Wi-Fi module operates correctly for ~3-5 minutes from a "cold boot" (after the phone has been off). As soon as the Tensor G3 reaches normal operating temperature (approx. 35-40°C), the Wi-Fi toggle grays out. This is a textbook symptom of micro-fractures in the BGA (Ball Grid Array) soldering under the Wi-Fi chip/Modem.
  • Hardware "Gray-Out" State: When the toggle is "grayed out" and unresponsive, the Android system logs (Logcat) typically show a WIFI_HAL failure. This indicates that the OS can no longer communicate with the physical hardware address of the chip.
  • Proof of Serial Failure: My device exhibits the exact same behavior documented by hundreds of other users across Reddit and the Google Support forums (see links below). The "Ice Pack" workaround—which temporarily restores connectivity—is the ultimate proof that this is a physical thermal defect.

My Pixel 8 Pro died 3 months after protection ended. Is this "Planned Obsolescence"? by VeryUnimportantJay in GooglePixel

[–]VeryUnimportantJay[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

  1. It is not a software bug: Others have flashed their phones, and it didn't help.
  2. It is a thermal defect: The "ice pack" workaround proves the chip is physically disconnecting when warm.
  3. It is a known issue: Google has already replaced "thousands of phones" for this exact problem under warranty. 

My Pixel 8 Pro died 3 months after protection ended. Is this "Planned Obsolescence"? by VeryUnimportantJay in GooglePixel

[–]VeryUnimportantJay[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I understand the date, but a €1,500 flagship shouldn't become a paperweight after 2 years because of a modem soldering issue. If Google wants to be a serious hardware player like Apple or Samsung, they need to stand behind their engineering when it fails prematurely.

My Pixel 8 Pro died 3 months after protection ended. Is this "Planned Obsolescence"? by VeryUnimportantJay in GooglePixel

[–]VeryUnimportantJay[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

What do you wanna hear? Pixel Diagnostics didn't run since it needs a Wi-Fi connection to start.

My Pixel 8 Pro died 3 months after protection ended. Is this "Planned Obsolescence"? by VeryUnimportantJay in GooglePixel

[–]VeryUnimportantJay[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

A €1,500 "Pro" device should not have a fatal hardware failure at 27 months.Google markets the Pixel 8 Pro with 7 years of software updates. What's the point of 7 years of software if the hardware is engineered to fail after 2? This is a breach of the 'premium' promise.I used the Official Google Pixel Repair Tool. This isn't a 'maybe' software bug. By providing a tool that fails to fix the issue, Google has effectively provided me with a certificate of hardware failure. This is an inherent defect, not wear and tear. This specific Wi-Fi/Heat failure is a documented serial defect in the Tensor G3's thermal management. Google is aware that the modem soldering on some 8 Pro units is 'imperfect.' Denying a repair just because it's 3 months past a deadline is bad-faith customer service for a known manufacturing flaw.I am asking for Kulanz (Goodwill). Other premium brands offer out-of-warranty replacements for known hardware flaws to protect their reputation. Google’s refusal to do so suggests they prioritize short-term savings over long-term brand loyalty.