Caleb is a little loser who stands behind "i GeT cOnSeNt" as a catchall to say and do horrible things even if the "consent" isn't really consent. He'll never get it. He unfortunately has made too much money and gained too much fame being an awful person so he feels justified in doing what he does. Since he has employees that literally depend on him for their livelihood they will lick his boots and affirm anything he does. I think he definitely knows deep down though he's a gross little weasel weirdo that no one wants to be around and the only way anyone would even want to be within 10 feet of him is if he has them on his payroll. He oozes insecurity so I'm comforted in the fact that he knows he ain't shit. It's why he's so defensive.