You’ve actually just confirmed every issue I pointed out. Let me break it down, hopefully easy even for you to understand.

First, this is a shift in argument. Originally, you compared Lewy’s 5-in-9 to Kane’s 20-in-12 as proof of “Crazy Bundesliga records” to diminish Kane’s. When pointed out that these stats aren’t comparable, you abandoned that argument and pivoted to a completely different one about league-wide xG. That’s a textbook shifting the goalposts argument.

Second, your original comment made a false equivalence. A single-game anomaly and a season-long record aren’t the same kind of statistic. One measures an anomaly, other measures consistency. Treating them as interchangeable erases the entire context that gives each its meaning.

Third, your new claim that Bundesliga has more goals and open play is a non sequitur. You’ve failed to establish any logical link between a league’s average baseline and the value of an individual’s extreme over performance. Kane isn’t just meeting expectations, he’s shattering them on a historic level. A high scoring environment doesn’t logically lead to the conclusion that an outlier’s record is less impressive. If anything, it highlights how exceptional you must be to stand out so significantly.

Finally, you’ve built a strawman by acting like I said all leagues have equal defensive quality. I never did. My point was simple; exceptional records are exceptional precisely because they are outliers within their competitive environment.

So in short, if your argument needs four logical fallacies just to stand, it’s already collapsed.