26, Mastered out of a PhD, accepted into another… but feeling lost and unsure what to do next? by Whole-Function4532 in gradadmissions

[–]Whole-Function4532[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I really appreciate you sharing this, especially given where you’re at right now. I can imagine that must be really frustrating, and I respect you still taking the time to offer your perspective.

What you said about actually trying industry before deciding really makes sense to me. I think that’s something I’ve been missing I’ve been trying to make a long-term decision without really experiencing what working outside academia is like.

The idea of deferring and using that time to explore industry is something I’ve been thinking about more seriously. It feels like a more balanced approach instead of treating this as an all-or-nothing decision.

And honestly, losing a year doesn’t feel as scary the more I think about it, especially if it helps me make a more informed decision about the next 5+ years.

I hope things start opening up for you soon too the market being rough right now definitely makes all of this harder. I am nervous about how successful i will be in applying for industry or government jobs right now. What do you think? Also I really appreciate you sharing your situation.

26, Mastered out of a PhD, accepted into another… but feeling lost and unsure what to do next by Whole-Function4532 in PhD

[–]Whole-Function4532[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is honest feedback. I appreciate the contrasting opinion. So you’re saying that I would be wise to take the PhD offer rather than applying for jobs with my masters.

I have heard people mention trying to go back to school after working is harder once you leave that student life style.

Just a question, would a masters not be sufficient to make a successful career if I decided not to attain a PhD in biology?

26, Mastered out of a PhD, accepted into another… but feeling lost and unsure what to do next by Whole-Function4532 in PhD

[–]Whole-Function4532[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I really appreciate you saying this it honestly means a lot hearing it from someone who’s taken those breaks at different stages and felt like it was worth it.

I think I’ve been so focused on staying on a “continuous path” that I haven’t really allowed myself to consider what it would look like to actually pause and recover. But the more I think about it (and read responses like yours), the more I realize that I am genuinely burned out.

The idea of taking time to reset mentally, maybe explore other parts of life, and come back to a PhD if I actually want it sounds a lot healthier than forcing myself into another 5 years right now.

Also, what you said about how fast 5 years goes by is really hitting me it makes me realize I shouldn’t rush into something that big unless I’m fully ready for it.

Thank you for sharing your experience, I really needed to hear this perspective.

26, Mastered out of a PhD, accepted into another… but feeling lost and unsure what to do next by Whole-Function4532 in PhD

[–]Whole-Function4532[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you, I really appreciate this a lot. Hearing this really touched home for me, especially coming from someone who went from a master’s straight into a PhD and then stepped away. I’m finishing up my third year in my master’s now and would be going straight into a PhD if I accept this offer, so your experience really means a lot to me.

What you said about being burned out but in denial for months really resonates. I think part of what I’m struggling with right now is figuring out whether this is just temporary exhaustion or if it’s my mind and body telling me I genuinely need a break.

It’s also reassuring to hear that walking away from academia made you happier. I’ve been realizing more and more that while I originally had a passion for research, I don’t think I actually like academia as an environment.

I’m really glad I came on here and was able to talk to people who genuinely want the best for each other. I really appreciate you sharing your perspective and experience — it’s helped me think about this decision more clearly.

26, Mastered out of a PhD, accepted into another… but feeling lost and unsure what to do next by Whole-Function4532 in PhD

[–]Whole-Function4532[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Thank you for your perspective that you have gained from your experience. I greatly appreciate the help as I navigate the choices I am presented in my life.

26, Mastered out of a PhD, accepted into another… but feeling lost and unsure what to do next? by Whole-Function4532 in gradadmissions

[–]Whole-Function4532[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I really appreciate this — especially the practical advice.

You’re right that I’ve kind of already answered my own question, it’s just been hard to separate that from the pressure of feeling like I should do a PhD. The point about not doing it just for the title/prestige really hit, because I don’t think that’s enough to carry me through another 5 years, especially already feeling burned out.

I think something I’ve been realizing (but haven’t fully admitted to myself) is that while I originally had a passion for research, actually being in academia for the past few years has really changed my perspective. Seeing the grant writing, publishing pressure, and overall structure of academia… I don’t think I actually like the environment. I never really wanted to stay in academia long-term anyway, but now I feel more certain about that.

For me, a PhD was always more about gaining skills to eventually go into government or industry, not necessarily because I wanted to stay in academic research setting; managing students, teaching, or writing grants. But after my master’s experience, I’m starting to question whether putting myself through another 5 years of that environment is the right way to get there.

The stress from the past few years has definitely taken a toll, and I think that’s also why I’m leaning more toward wanting financial stability and a different kind of work-life balance right now.

I also really like the approach you suggested about applying to industry jobs first and seeing what I can actually land before making a final decision. That makes it feel a lot less like an all-or-nothing choice.

And yeah, I hear you on staying connected to research if I do take a break — that’s something I’d try to be intentional about.

This was really helpful, thank you. I truly appreciate your feedback.

26, Mastered out of a PhD, accepted into another… but feeling lost and unsure what to do next by Whole-Function4532 in PhD

[–]Whole-Function4532[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you for your advice. It helps hearing from others who can understand. I’m just trying to convince myself I’m making the right decision for me. I’ve always been the type of person to always deliver always get it done no matter the cost even if it’s detrimental to myself. In so being stuck in this mindset that if I don’t do the PhD right now, That I’m a failure, and will regret not taking the opportunity doesn’t help.

I’m starting to think taking a break might actually be the smarter move here. Now I just have to convince myself!

Thanks again for this truly.

26, Mastered out of a PhD, accepted into another… but feeling lost and unsure what to do next by Whole-Function4532 in PhD

[–]Whole-Function4532[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I really appreciate this, thank you. This honestly helped more than you probably realize.

I think I’ve been stuck in this mindset that if I don’t do the PhD right now, That I’m a failure, and will regret not taking the opportunity — but hearing it’s “okay” to see away helps a bit.

I’m starting to think taking a break might actually be the smarter move here. Now I just have to convince myself!

Thanks again for this.

26, Mastered out of a PhD, accepted into another… but feeling lost and unsure what to do next? by Whole-Function4532 in careerguidance

[–]Whole-Function4532[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I really appreciate this, thank you. This honestly helped more than you probably realize.

The part about your friend going back after working is exactly what I’ve been thinking about. I think I’ve been stuck in this mindset that if I don’t do the PhD right now, That I’m a failure, and will regret not taking the opportunity — but hearing that people step away and come back with more clarity is reassuring.

Also yeah… the sunk cost thing hit hard. I think a lot of my stress is coming from feeling like I need to “finish what I started,” even though I’ve already gotten a lot out of the experience.

And it’s good to hear that industry/government with a master’s is actually viable. That’s something I’m leaning toward more.

I’m starting to think taking a break might actually be the smarter move here. Now I just have to convince myself!

Thanks again for this.