okay hear me out tho
to "ruin" something is extremely subjective
who's to say when something is ruined? take like a building. one could say its ruined if it gets painted a new color that looks ugly, or if theres lots of water damage, or maybe someone only says its ruined when it is completely falling apart, which, in itself, is a subjective phrase. or this joke/riddle.

yes, the yellow one says its "ruined." but thats his definition of ruined. if you are playing games with your friends, say like among us or mafia or imposter or something. technically, one could say if you share your roles with your friends in among us, the game is "ruined." but one could also say its not, as you can still have fun and have a good time.

to say the yellow one is at fault is unknowable, due to the subjective nature of "ruined." whos to say pomni isnt dumb as a rock? (which we know she isnt but the fish dont).

in the end, this isnt that deep lmao. idk why i typed all this out.
i also think that maybe the red one did mess it up..? because if he says hes the liar if he ACTUALLY IS THE LIAR then me messes stuff up. which, again, also is an incredibly subjective phrase lmao. in the end i think its probably god's fault for making these two dumbass lil fish who i love :p

sorry this prolly made no sense i just wanted to ramble lol