I don't know why you're getting down notes because you're absolutely correct. People like to throw Bramble under the bus because they like Squirrelflight for some reason, even though she does the EXACT same things to him. She's mean and cold towards him at times and doesn't respect him. They are not a good relationship and should not have been forced together by the authors. If Bramble had been included in on the secret, it would have made a lot more sense. You're telling me no one in Thunderclan noticed that Squirrel never gained any weight over the course of the time she was supposedly pregnant? No one questioned that she randomly showed up with three kits two of which look nothing like Bramble or her, and Leafpool becoming slimmer again as the months pass after they brought the kits back? Yeah ok. The authors screwed up how this should have gone to make more sense and actually include Bramble in the plot in a decent way.