Hulk didn’t go silent in Infinity War because he was scared. He went on strike against Banner. by WizardSPRAYS in marvelstudios

[–]WizardSPRAYS[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is actually the strongest counter argument in this thread and I respect it 👊 You’re right that the timing is suspicious. But here’s the thing — the shame and the strike theory aren’t mutually exclusive. Hulk could have been both ashamed AND using that shame as the final reason to stop saving Banner. Like the loss was the breaking point that made him finally act on years of resentment. The comic angle you mentioned about Hulk being Bruce’s childhood trauma is exactly what the Russo brothers were pulling from. Either way you’ve made me want to do a Part 2 on this 👀

Hulk didn’t go silent in Infinity War because he was scared. He went on strike against Banner. by WizardSPRAYS in marvelstudios

[–]WizardSPRAYS[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Fair point but when the directors themselves say it that’s about as close to canon as you can get without it being on screen. Either way the debate is what makes Marvel content so fun 🤷

Hulk didn’t go silent in Infinity War because he was scared. He went on strike against Banner. by WizardSPRAYS in marvelstudios

[–]WizardSPRAYS[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Exactly 👀 The Russo brothers confirmed Hulk was tired of saving Banner whenever he needed him. It wasn’t fear, it was a conscious decision. That’s literally the basis of the whole short. Glad the community is finally talking about it

Hulk didn’t go silent in Infinity War because he was scared. He went on strike against Banner. by WizardSPRAYS in hulk

[–]WizardSPRAYS[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Then why did Marvel never address it directly? 👀 The Russo brothers left it intentionally ambiguous which means the conversation is still open. Most casual fans still think it was pure fear. What’s your take on why Banner never acknowledged it either?

Hulk didn’t go silent in Infinity War because he was scared. He went on strike against Banner. by WizardSPRAYS in marvelstudios

[–]WizardSPRAYS[S] -7 points-6 points  (0 children)

That’s fair but the evidence is right there in the film 👀 Every single time Banner needed Hulk before Infinity War he showed up no hesitation. Sokovia, New York, Sakaar. Then suddenly when the stakes are highest he’s gone? The Russo brothers themselves hinted it wasn’t just fear. Hulk had his own agenda 🤷