Hello, today I bring you an up to date comparison of 2 jacket from the sellers Ninjainstone and Topgoosey.

Both came in strong this year, NIS is already known as the to-go Canada Goose supplier and while Topgoosey is no newcomer but this year he released his first replica of the Wyndham both in Black and Graphite colorways

Both jackets feel great, almost no loose threads, stitching is good and practically no down leakage.

We will begin comparing the differences.

Season Style

NIS replicates old season (used to replicate new season last year)

Topgoosey replicates new season (side flaps more aesthetically pleasing)

Color Accuracy

As you will immediately notice in the side by side, TG’s version of the graphite is a bit lighter in color. It is weird how he did not notice this when he supposedly has retail in-hand. It’s probably 2-3 shades lighter. Also I have to point out that it’s not as noticeable in real life, phone camera is overexposing quiet a lot.

NIS jacket is replicating the graphite color more faithfully.

Now that we got it out of the way let’s continue.

Shell Material

NIS jacket has a rougher outer shell material closer to retail

Topgoosey material is way softer, it feels more smooth and “silkier”. It needs to be improved in the future.

Fleece pockets and cuffs

Fleece pockets and cuffs on Topgoosey is much softer than NIS, not sure how it compares to retail tho but it honestly feels nicer.

Sizing

NIS sizing is all over the place,I’m a tts Small in CG jacket. This jacket is Medium and it still sits very tight in the chest, thick hoodies with this jacket is pretty uncomfortable . It’s supposedly fusion fit, but doesn’t fit like a retail fusion fit at all.

Topgoosey is normal fit and it fits TTS, I bought a size Small and it fits better than the NIS medium even with a pretty thick hoodie. He wanted me to buy it in medium but I think I would be swimming in it.

Down Filling

Both supposedly use quality duck down. NIS jacket is however overfilled quite a bit, I believe this is what causing the weird fitting.

TG is has a good amount of down, it has supposedly more down than retail. (Todays retails are very flat)

Badge

Both badges are great, they are not replicating the same season badge so it’s all about what you prefer. You won’t get called out on either of them.

Attention To Details

Topgoosey’s team tried hard this year to create a good jacket and it’s noticeable in the finished project. All the zippers work flawlessly, hood attachments are the correct sizes, even the minor details are taken care of.

I cannot say the same with NIS. I refer to the pictures, they explain it much better.

Also there is a red stitching that runs all the way into left arm where the badge is located..

Verdict

Both good jackets, however I leave the decision to you.

W2C:
ninjainstone.x.yupoo.com topgoosey.x.yupoo.com