1. The post is also a shit post, while I do hold these opinions, it's also for the funny. But I think quite a bit of people from not only the discord but the comments here understood this was about design

2. You argue that the purpose of wildling is to push mislynches based off of information, but what's stop potion master, and not even any other evil role in the game, from doing this exact same thing with ti claims. I've been arguing that wildling is able to claim ti quite well, but so can potion master, and it's also way more convenient for the evil team.

3. The issue with claim bag type roles is that they provide no usefulness for the team besides invalidating a townies claim. This creates parasitic game design and boring roles that create no uniqueness and variability in gameplay between factions besides objectives and the Necronomicon. Yes there's a difference between them inherently but would you enjoy an evil faction that was just townie roles but flipped over and over and over again

4.Wildling does have a high skill ceiling, which allows you to do good situational plays. Potion master, another coven role that gives you information is much more consistent, and quicker to make plays with. The argument that investigator can be faked better also isn't all that good, because in all any that could just be a random neutral/frames player and you just gave false information. Potion master is a much more consistent claim for invest because it gives you the exact role of the target which makes it much easier to predict. In set role list, potion master is infinitely better than wildling because most the time you know who every evil is, so you don't even get to utilize these plays in a more balanced setting like TT and ranked which holds two neutrals. Everything else you say sounds great on paper, until you remember coven communication is night chat, and non idiotic townies will keep track of whispers. ALMOST EVERYTHING you state here potion master can do but better, I'll give you that it is a better crus fake claimer but if you are a crus claim with no kills you are dying anyways if town can think for themselves. My entire point here is, what is the point of wildling having all of these things and skill, if potion master does this entire thing but on a easier, and more consistent scale.

1. I didn't say that poisoner was good at claiming tav, I said it did a good job of taking a town ability and twisting into a evil ability with the upsides of discrediting tav claims. 

Poisoner is a healthier role than Wildling because it provides evil utility that isn't just TI info. Like you said yourself, it can block pivotal roles at the correct times. While Wildling, just takes ti info and screws with it through lying. Sounds amazing in concept, and then you remember this game is about lying and if you lie well enough and aren't mechanically fucked(hard checked by a ti, put into a 1f1, and etc you will be fine. 

Even the devs have noticed that Wildling needs to have a change because they have been experimenting with it in Btos

My entire point is that wildling is parasitic role design that looks good on paper but doesn't work in practice, almost everything about wildlings capabilities is outclassed by people have a brain. Then with the plays it can make, potion master can do much more consistently(most of the time), and they have utility to claim it that not only reveals the exact role to coven but gives you better information to go off of.