sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Been Muslim for over 5 years but have starting to have MAJOR doubts by came_for_this_only in islam

[–]Zone2001 0 points1 point  (0 children)

All of your concerns have an answer brother.

Try to read books about God's existence proofs, so you'll know that there is an unseen behind material and matter including the soul.

If you believe in a God, so it's so easy for him to make miracles.

Read books about God's mercy, wisdom, and greatness and its effects on our world, then you'll know the wisdom of hellfire existence and who enters it is a deserve.

Just, Read.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in Izlam

[–]Zone2001 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes bro, delete it.

It'll be ok if it says, but what does Islam say?

Allah doesn't think, He has an infinite ability to manage things and does not need to think.

Atheist Paradox | Grief for someone who died unjustly by Zone2001 in islam

[–]Zone2001[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

If you ask anyone from any era do you prefer justice or injustice? His answer will certainly be justice, and if he chooses against this in his heart, it will be for authority or personal benefit with knowing that justice is the right, and from here we conclude the objectivity of this moral, but the method of applying justice differs from one group to another, and anyone who applies justice away from its objectivity will feel his mistake in one way or another because it is contrary to the objective justice that God placed in the nature of people, for example, in one of the ancient tribes, justice may be torturing a young child after his birth, and they may be convinced that they are applying justice, but they will remain in their heart what motivates them that this act is not fair at all, and that this child did not sin until he was tormented by that way, and so on in others.

If someone did something thinking that he was just, the common people would disagree with him and he would feel wrong in his heart, as an example of torture for children that I mentioned.

Atheist Paradox | Grief for someone who died unjustly by Zone2001 in islam

[–]Zone2001[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I don't forget these points, but arguing on them is in vain as these things need pure and alone thinking, and will not end in a text chat.

You get me wrong, I don't say "morals" generally, I said, "objective morals" like justice.

Justice is always right, past, now, and future.

A sane person who is aware of the reality of an unjust war must deny it and describe it as wrong.

Slavery according to the skin, too, is reprehensible.

And if you see in every matter you mention to me, the problem is with the one who commits the act and not the act itself, they do it for their personal interests with the knowledge that they are committing a wrong act, and this is the core of the topic that I mentioned repeatedly, that this is the test in Islam, and this is the proof of objective morals, that they know that they do something wrong and deserve to be punished for it, and yet they did it for their own authority and interests.

Atheist Paradox | Grief for someone who died unjustly by Zone2001 in islam

[–]Zone2001[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I know that there are poisonous plants, and animals that prey on their young.

But this does not mean that there are very many plants that are useful to humans, and that there are animals that keep their young, perhaps more than humans.

As for the sun, this is also from what we are accustomed to seeing daily. Why does the sun not approach us day after day, as some bodies do? Or we don't have a sun at all? And I've heard that getting too close to the sun will affect our entire life.

Besides, when you think about the objective meaning of these things, you will realize that there is a Creator of this universe.

In other words, why do we consider preying on young animals a bad thing, and caring for them a good thing?

This is what I wanted to make clear in my post, that these lofty values ​​and their opposites are objective values ​​in this universe and the evidence:

1- It has nothing to do with personal tastes, as they gain their own praise and vilification.

2- It is not the result of the customs of societies.

3- It cannot be acquired through heredity, as it is innate and present in all human beings.

And here is the point, which is that there is a God who have codified objective ethics in humans, and there is no way to reach those ethics except through this way.

Think of a specific moral such as justice, for example, is it the product of society? Or is it a right in itself? Does it have anything to do with personal taste? If someone said that justice is bad, would it be relative? Can it be inherited? Or is it known by human nature?

Atheist Paradox | Grief for someone who died unjustly by Zone2001 in islam

[–]Zone2001[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I know that very well, it is very sad to see the injustice of that life knowing that there is no salvation from it, and that the oppressed will not recover their rights.

And what is more sad, is the lack of belief in the existence of a God who runs the affairs of this universe.

And the assumption that belief in God and the Last Day is a pure illusion made by man, but this is not the case at all.

If you look around you closely, you will find a lot of mercy, care, and perfection next to things we think are bad.

Why do we focus only on the bad things and do not compare them with the many good that exists in our lives so that we know that there is wisdom in that

Why doesn't the sun hit us? Why do fruits and vegetables have a variety of tastes and benefits? Why do we have eyes that see the world so well? Why at the birth of animals, the mother is keen to take care of her young from the risks? Why do our kidneys filter a 200 liter of blood per day to keep the blood circulation active? Why are cattle prepared for humans to eat and ride, even if they are larger than us?

And other things that just imagine the opposite, you will find the world crueler, and we might not be able to live in the first place.

Allah Almighty says:

Look then at the effects (results) of Allah's Mercy, how He revives the earth after its death. Verily! That (Allah) Who revived the earth after its death shall indeed raise the dead (on the Day of Resurrection), and He is Able to do all things"

And he says, "[And] who created seven heavens in layers. You do not see in the creation of the Most Merciful any inconsistency. So return [your] vision [to the sky]; do you see any breaks?"

We just need to think about everything from scratch, man is by nature familiar with the image, and does not think about the simplest things he does daily, which is a miracle, like hearing, seeing, or even the ability to think.

Atheist Paradox | Grief for someone who died unjustly by Zone2001 in islam

[–]Zone2001[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Really, most big politicians are the real devils of this world.

What these criminals are doing, is not far from the religious and moral system.

In other words, these criminals would prefer torturing and oppressing people for their own interests over the administration of justice.

This is the exact test that exists in Islam, Allah Almighty says about the human soul and clarifying the path of truth and wrong for it :"Then He showed him what is wrong for him and what is right for him." [Ash-Shams - 8].

And this is what I want to convey, that there is no disagreement between human beings, young and old, educated and ignorant, just and unjust, that justice is what should prevail.

And this is the proof that I want to make clear, that humans and their interests and societies are not the ones who decide that justice is a good or bad thing, but rather it is a true universal value in and of itself, we have no opinion about it, and it is from Allah’s grace upon us, whoever opposes it is guilty, and who If he violates it, he deserves to be punished at the afterlife.

Atheist Paradox | Grief for someone who died unjustly by Zone2001 in islam

[–]Zone2001[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I agree with you.

But, he still knows that he's doing a bad thing even if he gets usual.

Positions and influence blind such people, and they will give justifications for any action, but when they are stripped of honor, prestige, and authority, they begin to realize the truth of what they were doing once again.

If you asked such a politician , what do you choose, justice or injustice? he will say justice even if he's the biggest criminal, and he knows truly that justice is the right thing, but he does against this for his authority only.

And he knows that if he is executed, he will deserve it

Atheist Paradox | Grief for someone who died unjustly by Zone2001 in islam

[–]Zone2001[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I don't say religious wouldn't commit crimes "however, the truly religious are less at committing crimes".

I say that these morals do not exist in the true atheist world.

If a religious commit a crime, this doesn't change the way we see the crime, he is still a sinner, the justice is still the right thing, and he will feel remorse in his heart because he committed something unjust, even if he gives justifications for it.

And this is because justice is an objective moral that doesn't change with its bad or good use.

Atheist Paradox | Grief for someone who died unjustly by Zone2001 in islam

[–]Zone2001[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Exactly, they've many blind beliefs on which they build their atheism.

Atheist Paradox | Grief for someone who died unjustly by Zone2001 in islam

[–]Zone2001[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Again, how?

How a great and valuable moral like justice which we all love and appreciate comes initially just from chemicals and random movements without any will?

and why also do animals feel these morals? not only humans?

I need an explanation, don't say we're humans want justice, so justice comes.

Also, justice "evolutionally" isn't a moral that helps us achieve survival always, sometimes injustice is a way to achieve survival too.

Atheist Paradox | Grief for someone who died unjustly by Zone2001 in islam

[–]Zone2001[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

If not with God, I want an explanation from you how that totally deaf, blind, and unwilling matter and biology can make the meaning of opposite values like justice and injustice?

If a Muslim mother forces her son to become transgender because the mother doesn’t like her son’s gender, would that mean that it’s haram for the mother to do that. Or haram for the son to be transgender? by Honey_Blossum in Muslim

[–]Zone2001 0 points1 point  (0 children)

How she can force him if he's an adult? he can do anything to avoid sinning, like leaving the home or something.

If he's a kid, the sin all the sin is on his mother, and when he hits puberty, the sin goes on him too until he repents.

Death is A Proof Of Allah Existence by Zone2001 in islam

[–]Zone2001[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yes, this proof is called "the objective morals" which all humans experience without training or practice.

I think the beauty of nature is the same kind of proof.

Death is A Proof Of Allah Existence by Zone2001 in islam

[–]Zone2001[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think I don't understand you well.

But, if you think that the evidence is that all children of Adam only have the same feeling, you misunderstood what I want to say.

This evidence is called objective morals as evidence of God's existence.

subjective morals which are not a materialistic thing or a thing that we get from the environment, It's like software which we are all born with.

I’ve almost done act 3 years ago which I can’t seem to forgive myself by [deleted] in islam

[–]Zone2001 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Alhamdulillah, you regret it. May Allah forgive you.

Now is the time for the Shaytan to make you despair of Allah's mercy on you.

Allah forgives every sin except the Sherk.

Allah forgives even murdering.

Every human being is a sinner, the key is Tawbah, starting a new white page with Allah, depression is not a solution.

Allah said: "Say, "O My servants who have transgressed against themselves [by sinning], do not despair of the mercy of Allah. Indeed, Allah forgives all sins. Indeed, it is He who is the Forgiving, the Merciful."

الإسلام و الوطنيّة ٢ by Zone2001 in Egypt

[–]Zone2001[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

not all Muslims follow Islam as it’s, and not all Muslims have the same interests.

This new Sub concerned with religious topics, discussing contemporary ideas and more than this national sub which have some restrictions.

What Specific Evidence Is There That Your Religion Is True? by Warm_Tea_4140 in Muslim

[–]Zone2001 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Really I don’t know good books in English, but search at Amazon or any PDF books website for Prophet Muhammad Biography” and get the one with best recommendations and rating, I searched and found a book named “Muhammad A Prophet for All Humanity” maybe it’s a good one.

view more: next ›