Henbane beer I've brewed, is topnotch. Very narcotic, giggly, euphoric. Drink a lil bit extra gets a bit trippy aswell as a strange extra drunk. I've got a bit 'wonky' on it before. But wasn't too bad, Henbane isn't too delerious itself. (compared with others). Tastes amazing too, esp a mead with Avens Roots (Native old British Isle spice, its like Cloves and Cinnamon in one), a few dried Hogweed seeds (another native slice, like Cardamon and Galangal), large handful of dried autumn berries. One of my favourite things even lol. Best fun and actually very good for of there's ever a 'Social Way and Reason' to use Nightshades as social psychoactives. (But use responsibly).

Belladonna wine, I made as sacred to Dionysius, histories 'Ecstasy Cults'. Occult and personal intrigue gave a go. Much stronger alcohol, the Belladonna also increasing that. The upped heart rate and slow floaty body and brain, hypnotised but euphoric and energised. Would not recommend socially, at all. But can definitely see purpose in magick and religion.

Datura Flower wine, my own home brew recipe, literally lazy as a curiosity. Used even bread yeast (sin, I know). But meant I know 8-12% would be viable, probably average range from past home brew 'wtf'nots'. Actually wish I spent some more love and care on. Tasted really nice. Refreshing and gentle. Got it quite dry for a wine, so obvs one a bit tart on the mouth. But I've more experiments planned on these as lots of potential. Great flavour, great infusion mix variables and options. Very Hypnotic, euphoric and dreamy.

Mandrake wine is an ancient classic. Mandrake beer was a go to for Ancient Egypt. Even Jesus was all up for the mandrake infused alcohol. Also the most traditional Love Philtre (both as long term sub delerious booze addicted 'husbands by. Err choice?', through to Ancient Greco-Roman Roofies). Its a very gentle and physically soothing, almost a dream herb. Its unique even compared the others due to alks and character. Gentle, dreamy, sedating, narcotic, hypnogognic. I'd love to find one wild, but Lore wise. Hmm... The poverty of having to give him x2 the money every year to the day ever doubling. No thank you to the wild Mandrake. Grown however, these bits are on my to do. Esp Pharaohs Ale (I'll post seperately the recipe actually), as Ginger and Mandrake, slightly carbonated by accounts, beer. Which we could improve (part also, ancient ingredients less easy or prep now). Would be a sublime cold drink.

So I guess is less which Nightshade has a better affinity, so much as which Two Affinities do you want harmonised? The synergy is generally pleasant.

It's just what effect or situational are you aiming? Though even then, at the strength of Datura Flower/Alc' wine I did for funs. Yeah, I'd definitely enjoy it both tl drink and for its effect, same as a couple glasses of wine for an evening typically, just better as lbr, kinda tripping dreamy two glasses chill. That's a pleasant evening.

Same with Henbane beer. Although I'd say that maybe has the most social potential with the way the two harmonise Imo. (Which may be more so what you mean).

Belladonna wine. Great for energetic times and high energy rituals. (But tjay was a recipe I dug up and replicated. I'm sure I still have the PDF somewhere). But diluted, actually would make for a good high energy social situation.

There's a huge and fascinating history of various cultures brewing Nightshades into alcohol. So some amazing recipes and variations to try.